I was also there on Wednesday night, and after having seen Headley, I was really let down by Jennifer Holliday. She isn't a disaster and does indeed sound lovely, but I found her scenes awkward and stifled. There were several line readings that made me laugh unintentionally- she understands the character fine, but she's not a skilled enough actress to disguise how clunky the book is. In general, actually, I found most of the new supporting cast far too broad, causing the show to lose some of its delicacy. It's still a great and moving production and Cynthia Erivo continues to be remarkable, but I wasn't bowled over like I was the first time I went.
I am a firm believer in serendipity- all the random pieces coming together in one wonderful moment, when suddenly you see what their purpose was all along.