Prefacing this rave with the understanding that, as with any piece in development, there is still work to be done... but I saw this yesterday (7/30) and was totally amazed. I can't stop thinking about it and would definitely encourage anyone at a reasonable distance to spontaneously make a trip and catch one of the final performances. My boyfriend and I had to return to NYC yesterday evening, but we're turning around after work today and heading back to Williamstown to see it one more time (and will definitely travel to wherever it pops up next).
It's hard to describe what feels so new, but the comparisons to Evita make sense as far as the structure/flow and the central powerful woman. I also might compare it in certain ways to Here Lies Love, to Great Comet (makes sense w/ Rachel Chavkin) in terms of its contemporary score and direction. The book is very simple, very straightforward/easy, which at first surprised me, but proved helpful considering the magnitude of the story and score (many locations, role doubling, spanning many years, covering various episodes in history). It might be argued that the book is not as original as the show as a whole, but for me it definitely worked and I was never once disengaged.
Eden is astounding. Needless to say, her voice is a force on its own, but her acting is the real treat of this performance, IMO. Her evolution is so nuanced and her act one finale was one of the most electric things I've seen live - every beat of her songs were packed with intention and her solo moments escalated so effectively/realistically - her movements in the songs, simple as the way she'd frame herself in a doorway, had me in tears.
Stating more of the obvious, Carmen Cusack is triumphant. Having such a diverse resume (Wicked, Sunday in the Park, Les Miz, Bright Star, Carrie, Phantom of the Opera etc.) I was blown away by her ability to deliver ANOTHER completely unique performance. Her range as an actress is incredible, and this score allows her to use her beautiful soprano, her smoky jazz voice, and, of course, her distinctive belt. She moves SO well in her numbers - her allure is effortless. She gives an evenly powerful performance, but I would single out "Stillness" and her act 2 duet with Eden as spine-chilling standouts.
I was also pleased to see that Rachel Tucker gets to shine and show off her singing chops in Act 2 - her talent is definitely not wasted (don't want to give away too much of the story, so won't go into detail). Most of the musical numbers are "BIG" but somehow it didn't feel too rote... others may disagree, but the story felt conducive to intense/ballady numbers. Maybe a few more breather moments could benefit a show that from start to finish is notably intense?
There are certainly areas for polishing (very minor cliches here and there/some ensemble issues/maybe some trimming could be helpful?), but I don't want to get into that considering the fine-tuning phase its in - anything I didn't enjoy (which were very few things) felt easily fixable. I could touch on the scenes between Eden and Andrew Samonsky which are juxtaposed SO effectively with the Carmen scenes, but I think I'll leave it at this for now! Go see it!!!!
I hope it transfers. No matter where it ends up, I'll be trekking to see it multiple times. It has SO much heart.
Updated On: 7/30/18 at 12:30 PM