I just got home from a showing, and I will say that this works much better as a movie musical than as a stage musical. As others have noted, the stage version was bloated, and the film's omission of many songs helps address this issue. Having seen the stage musical twice, my main complaint has always been its lack of bite compared to the 2004 film. There was no "Mean" in Mean Girls on Broadway. The movie musical recaptures some of that edge, but I agree with the observation that certain updates appeared somewhat pandering or like virtue signaling.
I had listened to a few clips of "Stupid With Love" before watching this, and I was surprised by the change in orchestrations. However, within the film's context, they do make more sense. Nonetheless, I remained baffled by Angourie Rice's casting. Her performance seemed lacking in both acting and singing, and I don't understand why she was the actress chosen.
Moving on to some positives: Renee Rapp's portrayal of Regina undeniably steals the show, and I have no complaints about listening to her sing. She also adds her own spin to Regina, a refreshing take on the role. Instead of mimicking Rachel McAdams, she's offered a contemporary interpretation. While some may not have been fans, "Someone Gets Hurt" was, without a doubt, my favorite scene in the movie.
I also want to briefly call out that Jaquel Spivey did an excellent job of making Damian his own, even while delivering some of the very iconic original lines.
Overall, I'd rate it a solid 3/5. While nothing will ever match the original movie, this adaptation comes a bit closer than the stage musical.
Updated On: 1/15/24 at 04:50 PM