iluvtheatertrash said: "uncageg said: "quizking101 said: "I saw the show last night and…I’m not sure what to make of it. I think I enjoyed myself?
THE GOOD:
- The Choreography: The Tony is already engraved with Wheeldon’s name on it. Bar none, some of the best choreography I’ve seen in almost 200 shows over 15 years. It hit all the right MJ notes while also having its own identity.
- Myles Frost: The audience (more on them later) acted as if he was the second coming and, honestly, I’m inclined to agree. His performance is uncanny and I could definitely see him being the hot contender for a Tony himself (he makes Hugh Jackman and Rob McClure look bland by comparison).
- Ayana George: If there was a runner up for the shows’ MVP, it’s her. She can SING and also has so much depth and warmth as Katherine Jackson while easily sliding in and out of a role as a backup singer.
THE BAD:
- The Book: I guess even Lynn Nottage hits a whammy once in a while. The framing device of the documentary is so painfully awkward and definitely skirts most controversies - watering down an otherwise complicated figure with very hacky dialogue and a written characterization that makes him out to be a weirdo. Also, the cuts to flashbacks and dance numbers are so extended that it drifts away from the main thread and you forget it’s a thing until you are jarred back.
- The Song Choices: So many snippets and songs did not belong there. What was that whole “For The Love Of Money” segment? It’s not even related to MJ at all. Also, the mega mix at the end with “Black or White” and “Wanna Be Starting Somethin’” was very clunky.
- “Thriller” - Undeniably a crowd pleaser but what the on earth was that design? It was like “Moulin Rouge From Hell”.
THE UGLY:
- The Audience: I don’t think I’ve ever seen a more horribly behaved audience in my life. Obviously, I’m amenable to verbal expressions and reactions in a theatre because, well, it’s live and that’s what happens. What I’m NOT amenable to is people having whole conversations during the show AND singing along at an audible volume (somehow through a mask). Also, the cell phone use was out of control. I counted at least ten people in my section of the mezzanine filming the show and the ushers running like mad to flash their lights, only for them to resume once they left. Finally, apparently 25% of the mezzanine last night didn’t read the start time on their tickets - since people were still showing up as late as 8:30pm and were disruptive in getting to their seats. I was truly horrified by all this nonsense…"
That set for "Thriller" was the cover of the "Dangerous" album and to this day I am trying to figure out why they did that. Were we supposed to get some meaning from it? Especially since they had done "Thriller" earlier in the show.
I went to the 2nd preview to hopefully avoid all of the bad audience behavior. Looks like I did. There were people filming but the ushers shut them down and threw two people out at intermission. It stopped in Act II. A few responses from audience members but not a lot. I want to see it again but I am sure, based on your comments and others, it has gotten worse and will drive me crazy!
"
They didn’t do Thriller earlier. They sampled about 20 seconds of it as part of the rehearsal they’re in. Nowhere near the same as doing the full song."
Ah, so they cut the first one. I think they should have kept the first one and cut the second time they did it. It was strange seeing it done with the the Dangerous album cover as the set. The first time they did it, when I saw it, was closer to the video.
Just give the world Love. - S. Wonder