Well, that was wild! This one's chaotic, fun, and gross, and I enjoyed it more and more as the plot took off and it leaned into its culty horror aspects. I couldn't think of a better place to spend International Women's Day.
Reading through earlier posts on here, it sounds like they've tweaked this a good deal over previews. I presume that they've cut some songs because the balance of songs versus book scenes felt right and the placement of the songs seemed appropriate. I'm excited to hear the score again and it's not overloaded by any means. I've already listened to the title song video that they've released a bunch of times, and it'll be stuck in my head for a while! However, a few songs slowed the momentum. They're highly enjoyable and get good reactions but either go on too long or don't feel like they're moving the plot forward as much as they could. There's room to improve the pacing, in my view. The plot takes its time to get going, and the fact that the set stays pretty stagnant early on exacerbates this - the earlier scenes feel like a lot of setup and the momentum doesn't pick up until the teeth come out. I agree with others that they could easily make this two acts. Alternatively, they could streamline the first half of the show before it goes full horror and get to the chomping faster.
Everyone was on tonight and the casting is top-notch. Alyse Alan Louis hits both the pure and unhinged beats, Steven Pasquale is spot-on in each of his roles, Jason Gotay's song about modesty is a hoot, and Jared Loftin just about walks away with each number and one-liner he's given. The audience, which was HIGHLY enthusiastic tonight, was especially into Loftin's performance. Each of the PKGs brought distinct personalities to their parts.
Will Connolly's acting is excellent and I found myself watching him a good amount, but I feel like the show isn't sure what it wants Brad's role to be. They set him up like he's going to be more of a foil than he is - they give him his backstory and Truthseeker scenes - but he doesn't feel like a true adversary to Dawn, and the time we spend with him doesn't feel completely justified as a result.
The ending sounds like it's indeed changed since earlier previews, based on the posts on here. In the current ending:
Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content
After Dawn offs Ryan, the PKGs start using their teeth, and Dawn/the PKGs defeat the Pastor, Dawn/Dentata faces off with Brad. It's a relatively brief, verbal face-off between the feminocracy and masculinity, they charge at each other, blackout. Then, Dawn, who won, speechifies for a bit and calls out the infidels in the audience, rallies the PKGs and her manservants, and they all sing together while coming toward the audience (something like "there is a monster..." if I remember correctly). I don't remember anyone chomping on an apple unless I missed it. We don't hear from Brad after the blackout.
The ending's tone worked for me, though I wasn't fully on board with the execution. As things went off the rails more I was hoping for a "Don't Feed the Plants" or "Carrie on a staircase covered in blood after killing everyone" type of mythical horror ending, and this hit the tone I wanted. But Dawn's speech went on a tad longer than it needed to, and the Brad vs. Dawn payoff felt somewhat anticlimactic because I wasn't sold on Brad as a character. I'd also have appreciated a more substantial confrontation between the Pastor and Dawn/the PKGs too. He's such a presence in the show but they just wordlessly kill him off and move on.
I'm curious to read the reviews and more reports as the run goes on to see if they continue to make changes, since it sounds like they're actively working to make improvements.
God, I love off-Broadway. It's weird, offbeat stuff like this that keeps theatregoing fun.