I saw this tonight--my first show on broadway since the summer--and I really enjoyed it. I'm sure there's not much to say beyond what's in the 19 pages of this thread (although I haven't read all of it), but wanted to report that Lauren Zakrin was on for Natasha. I actually missed the slip in my playbill because it was weirdly sticking to one of the pages, but I'm sort of glad because I didn't have that sense of disappointment you get when the slip falls out. I realized a few minutes in because the opening song identifies her as Natasha and I knew she wasn't Denee Benton, but by that time I was so taken with the immersive experience it barely registered.
Well I have no basis for comparison but I thought she was absolutely fantastic! I have seen some comments that Denee's voice is softer and that is not the case with Lauren. Her voice does remind me in some ways of Philippa's (although not quite as good), which doesn't surprise me since it appears from her bio in the playbill she's understudied the role from the beginning. (I think? it says Off-Broadway and at ART. I'm not familiar with all the iterations.) There was one song where I felt she was a little screechy on just a couple of notes, but it was the on song with a high belt. (I don't remember.) The rest of it she was sublime. And her acting was really fantastic. The bottom line is if you see a slip with her name on it, you should not be disappointed.
I sat in the stage rights banquettes and absolutely loved the seats. I definitely would not sit at the tables in front of Pierre's study and I can totally see why Luscious complained. I could barely see the people in those seats and there was a lot of action around me. The other tables would be cool in terms of the immersion, but I could see the people twisting and turning a lot to see certain parts of the action. For me, those onstage banquettes are perfect because you're very very close to the action and completely immersed in it, but you still are able to see absolutely everything. Highly recommend those seats!
The show is totally weird and like nothing I've ever seen and I loved every minute.