Last night all the main cast - Bernadette, Garber, Gavin, Kate seemed to fumble slightly at least once but quickly recovered. When Bernadette was doing the “money, money, money” monologue I also wondered whether she was doing it a bit slower to help her remember the lines. So I definitely take your point that there is still some time needed to settle in.
At the same time it’s hard not to ignore that so much work has been put into her performance to examine every moment and find a line delivery, facial expression or body movement to wrench as many laughs from the audience as possible. If I look at the hat shop scene, for example, there were many highlights. The way she transitions from excited/nervous to deliver a very deadpan “you’re killing me”. The Garber/Bernadette head turns towards/away from each other. The protection of the cupboard door such as the “ripple ripple ripple ripple” lines, the vocal expression pretending to be outraged and the hilarious very prolonged silence after Cornelius sneezes and she looks a little confused about how to proceed, going to talk then stopping at least twice - finally after keeping the audience on edge for so long tentatively proclaims “bless you”.
Her status does add to the experience - when she is walking with an umbrella (or should I say parasol rather) in “put on your Sunday clothes” it’s hard not to be reminded of the past. When she says the word “Folly” it also brings back memories. And when she is walking down those stairs and she is saying it’s good to be back where she belongs of course it feels like they could be talking about either the character or just herself. There is something novel about repeating a leading role with the same team that started to lead to her break out (Mack & Mabel).
But what I love - and hopefully I’m not wrong - is that there is enough substance in her performance. Enough comedy. Enough vulnerability. Enough voice (and most important a unique voice to keep it interesting) so that even the uninitiated will still have a good time and recommend the show to others.
Give me claws and a hunch, just away from this bunch.
Updated On: 1/26/18 at 07:57 AM