Saw the show tonight with a full house, attendees admitting at intermission that they were in heavily discounted seats. The vibe: Everyone wants to love this new show. You can feel it in the house. Me included. Hard working company giving unstintingly. The dancing is athletic and often stirring, if repetitive. There's a star making performance that will be widely admired, and deservedly. I’ll just add that the show around her feels adjusted by multiple hands, without a singular vision. You can feel the exposition dumps to clarify, and the presentational style - everything is played to the house - strips the show of needed intimacy, particularly in a non musical house like the Barrymore. I longed for two actors simply talking or singing to one another.
Some clearly find that the preaching to the (NYC) choir tone enhances the piece's relevance to 2022, whereas I’d appreciate drawing contemporary parallels without heavy handed annotation. Trust the sophisticated Broadway audience a little more. That pedantic component -- the show seems determined to teach us -- is not my taste. I prefer discovery. Probably a minority take. The cast is able and stellar and maybe it will catch fire. It’s hard to guess precisely what aspect inspires an advance and therein lies the problem once the heavy papering ebbs. Maybe I’m wrong. The response in the final 15 minutes certainly seemed heartfelt.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 3/30/22 at 10:53 PM