I was thinking about this show at work this morning...
This could have done very well (both critically and in the ratings) had it been done as a one-night only TV special. Hosting and main performances by Clay & Ruben, cut the awkward skits/dialogue and being in a legit team that could shape together bits, bring on other popular American Idol contestants, etc.
It’s a lot to expect people to pay actual money to see this product instead of paying in time at home. I don’t know how this was chosen as a limited-run show on Broadway when it could have been better in every possible way on television.
I am big. It’s the REVIVALS that got small.