Saw this last night! I went into it cold, so I wasn't sure what to expect other than the reverse chronological order and a couple of the songs I already knew, but man, I loved it! So funny and warm and heartbreaking, and I was invested from the very first scene.
Jonathan and DanRad seemed perfectly cast for their respective roles, and I'm delighted we were able to see them. I would have liked the chance to see Lindsay, too, but Jamila Sabares-Klemm was fantastic and I never would have guessed she was an understudy. In fact, she was my husband's favorite performer. The ensemble were all great, too - no one stuck out in a bad way to me.
We were in the front row, which is absolutely thrilling for this theater considering how close you are to all of the actors - it felt like it was being played for me specifically. Definitely want to see it on Broadway when it transfers, but I know it won't feel as intimate as it did at this theater!