I saw the show Monday night and am just now getting around to reviewing it.
The crowd around me seemed to be very excited and there were definitely some hardcore fans of the movie who don't typically attend the theatre. Overall though everyone was well-behaved and it wasn't the circus I thought it would be. That obviously could change post-opening, especially over the summer.
I'll start with the good. The sets are incredibly impressive. They're not exactly pretty but they capture the essence of an industrial, downtrodden neighborhood well enough and it's clear where the money in this show went. The pet store set is absolutely gorgeous with the projected tanks and it's impressive how technically everything moved so quickly and effortlessly. Definitely some of the better tech work I've seen recently.
The show also starts with a rousing ensemble number. "Ain't Down Yet" is actually a great way to open the show and the initial fight choreography was captivating. As soon as the ensemble trots off the stage and we're no longer immersed in sweeping sets, the show grinds to a halt.
Andy Karl delivers an uneven performance at best. In some scenes, his efforts to imitate Stallone fail incredibly flat. The accent, the mannerisms, it all seems incredibly inorganic and jarring. When he isn't imitating him, Karl fares better, but that's not the Rocky the audience is paying to see and it he'll quickly snap back into a third rate impression. I can only imagine how complicated this makes singing some of these, alternating between accents and different voices. It doesn't help that every number he's given as a solo is really trite with some incredibly juvenile lyrics. The songs also do nothing to advance the story. "Fight from the Heart", "Keep on Standing," "Adrian" all say just about nothing and are completely unmemorable.
Margo Seibert, on the other hand, does a wonderful job with the material she has. Her Adrian is a bit changed for the stage, but it all works well. She's also given some of the score's best songs. "Raining" and "I'm Done" are both beautiful numbers. Her voice soars and she's one of the brightest spots of the production. I have no idea how she hasn't gotten more work. The only problem with "I'm Done" is that there's almost no stake the audience has in her relationship with her brother. Paulie trots on and off the stage and stumbles around drunkenly but there's no real character development so "I'm Done" is largely a wasted number.
Terrence Archie was out and his understudy was fine in what was another poorly written role. He also got the most cringeworthy embarrassing number of the night, "Patriotic." No idea how that campy, out of place and unnecessary number is still in the show.
Dakin Matthews is good as Mickey and while his "In the Ring" number is a bit superfluous, it actually works as one of the show's few endearing, deeper moments.
The show is certainly strongest during the ensemble numbers. The "Eye of the Tiger" montage was well staged and even exhilarating. My only issue: those steps looked nothing like the steps at the PMA. The audience ate that part up though and also loved any nods to the movie.
The finale is entertaining enough and the transition didn't feel too long with all of the entrances and dialogue occurring simultaneously. It was thrilling when the ring moved forward and the fight was choreographed brilliantly. In the end though, this is certainly, as others have stated ad nauseum, a why musical. The score is bland, the performances (besides Seibert) are uneven at best. Only in the ensemble and fight numbers does the show truly take off and that only represents about 1/4 to 1/3 of the show. For my time and money, seeing the movie again would have been the better decision.
Scratch and claw for every day you're worth!
Make them drag you screaming from life, keep dreaming
You'll live forever here on earth.