Just saw the show tonight. Yowza! The first act is mediocre--the songs are silly and the plot doesn't really go anywhere, but there are some great visuals, and you can hold onto that hope that the pieces will all come together. But that second act! Holy crap! The book, the score, the design, the concept...EVERY piece goes off the rails.
To comment on the safety of the show: it looks much, much safer than any Cirque du Soleil show I've ever seen. Yes, there have been injuries, but watching tonight, I couldn't see where the Arachne character was in any more danger than, say, Jane Krakowski in Nine. I don't have the impression from watching it that it's terribly likely more people will be injured. And for the people freaking out, haven't there been a fair number of injuries at other shows--Wicked comes to mind.
But that's neither here nor there. Julie Taymor is a visionary in the strictest sense of the word, yes. She is possibly one of the best designers around. But I'm not fond of her directorial work other than The Lion King. Juan Darien and The Magic Flute left me cold. And I despised Titus and Across the Universe. She has incredible ideas, but she never seems to harness them terribly well. The Lion King is the exception, and I do wonder if since that was her most commercial project to date at the point, she simply had to cede some control to someone who could edit her.
The failure of Spider-Man isn't primarily her fault, though, in my eyes. I really think the heaviest blame has to lie on Bono and The Edge. The music is a disaster. It simply fails on every level. It isn't exciting rock. It doesn't move the action forward in the slightest. It doesn't create mood. And Arachne's shoe song in the second act is the most horrifyingly bad thing I've seen in any Broadway show since Brooklyn. And when you can actually make out words, well...it makes you wish you couldn't.
I saw some really nifty flying, and I got to look at some pretty things on stage. Other than that, the show really doesn't offer anything exciting, memorable, or even coherent. It's unfollowable for children and unengaging for adults. This will likely stick around for awhile--hell, The Addams Family is still performing well. But it's an enormous disappointment.
Lol -- you DO think that'd be menitioned one way or another!
(Maybe THAT'S the rope that hit Arachne in the head!)
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it?
These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
The web shooting only happens once, and it's kind of...it looks like he just tosses some string. It's a dud visually. It and two miniature Spider-Men stand out as the only real visual duds of the show.
I was also at the performance tonight or rather last night now that its 2 Am. I haven't decided whether I like it or not. I will just list a few things off the top of my head. **Possible Spoiler alert**
I felt like I was dreaming during the show. A lot of the unexpected, visually.
Some of the set looks like it popped out of a Dr. Seuss Book
The music wasn't great but it certainly didn't ruin the night.
I would like to ask Julie her reasoning for how she uses some of the characters. It seemed really odd with the comic book geeks always on the side of the stage.
Some of the costumes had a Tim Burton flair to them.
Vertigo...Really, they had to play the implement the song in the show?
The lighting was magnificent
I agree that children will have a hard time following the show, the whole way through with the way it is now.
Final thoughts: I couldn't get a sense of why this show is on Broadway. I think it has more of a Theme Park Show type attraction to it. With that in mind, Spiderman was something totally different than any show on Broadway, so maybe it is redefining theater. And good luck touring!
Herbie: "Honey, Don't you know there's a depression?"
Rose: "Of Course I know, I Watch Fox News"
-(modified)Gypsy
Broadway Schedule
December 5th- Hamilton, On Your Feet
December 19th- Noises Off, Edith Piaf Concert at Town Hall
For those who have seen performances other than the infamous first preview, was the show stopped for technical issues? How long is it currently running?
I heardWeds and thurs had one stop each, but I don't know about Fri/Sat nights.
I heard its still running about 3:10.
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it?
These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
A family member was there last night; I got a text at 9:27 that she was at intermission and there was one short stop in the first act. She liked the second act better than the first because she thinks they decided to actually tell the story rather than just fly around the theatre. They got out around 11:12.
bundy5000---you've helped me make a decision re: seeing this show. I've decided to NOT go because any performance that has the word "vertigo" in it's description is a definite no-go for me! :)
"If they were smart, they would never open and preview undefinitely."
I'm at a loss for the link - but I remember backstage footage of Carrie when it opened, when a cast member directly said: "We should've never opened. We should've previewed and previewed and previewed."
Recent Broadway and Off-Broadway:: Carrie, Merrily, Ionescopade
Next On The List :: Clybourne Park, Once, Streetcar, BOM
Carrie pushed back opening too, didn't they? I remember reading somewhere that instead of being at the end of the Tony season, like they wanted, they ended up opening at the beginning of the next. They had hoped to open at the end, get a nomination, get to perform, and bring in business that way.
Yep, there was one stop last night that was about two or three minutes long. And it ran just over three hours.
America as Arachne? I don't want to say much because I feel like any understudy going on in the first week of previews must be perilously underrehearsed. Let's just say that most of the performers really disappeared into the show because it's never really about the people. America...left the biggest impression.
That petition is one of the most mean-spirited things I've ever read. Right now, a large company of artists are frantically - and perhaps sleeplessly - working their asses off to try and realize their collective vision. I am absolutely appalled at the cruelty shown Ms. Taymor. And, why? She's a director, trying to mount production. She is not the first artist to dream big, and I hope to god, not the last.
Spider-man team, you go. Try your hardest to make this show fly.