I was at the second preview last night and had a positive reaction to this revival; the good definitely outweighs and overshadows the bad, so even a misstep is quickly forgotten five minutes later.
First off, I don't understand how anyone could call this a "staged concert." It's not. When someone tells me "staged concert" I assume the actors will be in evening formal wear seated at chairs on stage. They will come forward to act their scenes and sing their songs (often with books in hand), but the don't expect costumes, sets, choreography, etc. Compared to the Chicago revival (which is also a full production) the Sunset revival is downright lavish. Everyone is fully, often elaborately costumed, there is choreography, plenty of furniture and while the house isn't the gilded beast of the original, there is an extensive series of stairs that run all the way up both side of the Palace stage. The 40 piece orchestra doesn't hurt.
Close is spectacular and the main reason to see this production, well that and to hear the score. She's completely brilliant and seems to be having a blast. Yes she's older and her voice has a weak moment or two, but the feeling and emotion behind it! Wow! I'll argue with anyone here that Callas' best Norma recording is her 1960 recording with Ludwig and Corelli. She may be past her prime, but she has a deeper understand of Norma than in her previous "better" sung recordings and she simply becomes the character like no other after her. This is Close's 1960 Norma recording. It's a triumph and her big numbers are worth the visit to this revival.
The rest of the cast members don't exactly rise to the same level, but no one is giving a bad performance either. Too Much In Love To Care (one of my favorite ALW tunes ever) is great and the best moment for both Betty and Joe. I was never completely won over by Michael Xavier's Joe- he oscillates between slightly underwhelming and decently effective. Despite Max having one of the best songs in the show, the part is underwritten. Fred Johannson cracked on his big note- otherwise he played Max just as I imagine everyone has always basically played the part. There was no new revelation to be found here.
Joe's dead body hanging over the proceedings the entire time was rather silly. Sometimes I forgot about him dangling up there and then it caught my eye again I chuckled. When the body is raised out of the pool at the beginning why doesn't he just keep on rising up out of sight?
The score is easily in my top 3 ALW efforts and it's nice to hear it so richly played.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!