Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway) — Page 3

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#51

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

I wanted to love this one, but it was a bit too precious for me (including the adult actors playing kids in scenes) and the narration was just a bit too much for me. I think a lot of people will like this, but I don't see a lot of people loving it. Kelsee Kimmel gives a fantastic performance.
#52

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

My relationship with this musical is an interesting one. I loved it when I saw it off-West End with Jamie Parker and then was really cold to it when I saw the West End transfer to The Ambassadors. So I was really surprised when I found myself very moved again by it down at The Public. I can’t make sense of why, but I’m very glad I took the chance to see it again.

#54

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

steven22 said: "Just leaving the matinee. What a beautifullymoving production. I’m excited to go back in December and I hope it transfers or has a longer life elsewhere!"

I too was at today’s matinee but sadly had quite the opposite reaction.
Many songs sounded exactly the same to me, and I found Durand to be rather bland in the lead.
I’m not sure if this survives in a larger Bway house, and certainly won’t give Paddington or Warriors any competition at Tony time.

#55

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

If this actually moves to Broadway, it will (quickly) lose every dollar. It’s not the next ONCE or even the next KIMBERLY AKIMBO. It’s the next SWEPT AWAY or DEAD OUTLAW. It’s a shame since it was one of the shows I was most looking forward to.

#56

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

It's small which is helpful. It's also family friendly. It may come in as a "limited run" and see how it goes knowing it could possibly extend. It's coming and I wouldn't count it out come Tony time or with audiences. The show I saw the audience really enjoyed it and left happy - with good audible reviews. It could be the small show with heart opposite all the big and bloated options this spring.

#57

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

i thought this was quite good. yes, all the songs blend into one big song, but unlike Wanted (which I saw last night), that one song is rather beautiful, and the songs absolutely move the plot along. lot of sniffling in the second act, but nothing manipulative or even all that deep/complicated- just a story about the most basic thing in the world, the passage of time, but set to this fascinating old story. yes, its twee and the jokes are corny, but so much so that it feels like the lack of edge/nerve reads intentional. it works.

its another very strong ensemble of musicians/singers (Britney Coleman, who I remember from Company, is playing the violin like an aficianado?), led by the two leads: Kelsee Kimmel's understated turn--she has a simply remarkable voice that gets a few moments to break free-- and the real star here, Durand. What hes doing is incredible: he really does read OLD and then MIDDLE AGED and then YOUNG with barely any costume/makeup changes. I think--like in Dead Outlaw--he makes the impossible look very easy, and was perfectly cast with his plain but expressive features. He has a knack for playing different version so Everyman, and i think that really worked for this role. Button is a miracle, but also all of us, and Durand nails it. Really impressive.

No idea if this transfers, or how it would do more commercially. It seems to me that its a pretty marketable "name" for a story that would attract alot of people and with the right reviews/marketing, could be a sleeper hit. its certainly a rather universal and deeply moving message.

it was also Good Time Charlie's closing performance, and intermission was just a sea of Bway names and celebs lining up for act 2 of that show.

Updated On: 10/25/26 at 11:11 PM

#58

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

JSquared2 said: "If this actually moves to Broadway, it will (quickly) lose every dollar. It’s not the next ONCE or even the next KIMBERLY AKIMBO. It’s the next SWEPT AWAY or DEAD OUTLAW. It’s a shame since it was one of the shows I was most looking forward to."

I remember a whole thread of people confidently making the same proclamation about Schmigadoon.

#59

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

This will do fine if it transfers. For how long, who's to say? It has a well-known name, decent reviews, and it is a non-threatening choice that will be an easy yes for people looking tor a reliable feel-good production.

#60

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

It's also, likely, not that expensive to run. Small cast who play instruments and a small-ish set.
A Chorus Line revival played its final Broadway performance on August 17, 2008. The tour played its final performance on August 21, 2011. A new non-equity tour started in October 2012 played its final performance on March 23, 2013. Another non-equity tour launched on January 20, 2018. The tour ended its US run in Kansas City and then toured throughout Japan August & September 2018.
#61

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

OuttaTowner said: "I’m not sure if this survives in a larger Bway house, and certainly won’t give Paddington or Warriors any competition at Tony time."

I don’t know…maybe it won’t be seen as much of a contender for Best Musical, but it has my vote for Best Score over those other two.

#62

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

Emily Nussbaum comment from Goings On in the Nov. 2 New Yorker issue:

“The Curious Case of Benjamin Button” is a stunner—a gorgeously performed, gloriously staged, philosophically perverse fairy-tale musical that left me swooning. You may know the premise even if you haven’t read F. Scott Fitzgerald’s short story: a baby is born as an elderly man and ages backward; along the way, he struggles, has worldly adventures, and falls in love. Andrew Durand, with his handsome crab-apple features, makes a perfectly quizzical Benjamin; Kelsee Kimmel is stirring as his true love, who shares his age just once. The harmony-singing, instrument-playing ensemble is terrific, and the show’s strong score, by Darren Clark and Jethro Compton (who also wrote the book and directed), has a touch of “Hamilton” and a streak of “Come from Away.” Everything clicks: even the moon, swinging from a green net above the clever nautical set, stole the show.

#63

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

Just got an email about the Benjamin Button closing night benefit that included this sentence:

"Don't miss your LAST CHANCE to see this phenomenal show and celebrate its fantastic run at The Public after THREE EXTENSIONS."

The use of "last chance" as opposed to "last chance at the Public" might mean a transfer is on hold? Maybe reading too much into it but thought that was interesting

#66

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

I enjoyed this show and the production is first-rate. Durand is giving an award-winning performances. In recent years small and heartfelt musicals have found a niche in straight play houses ("Kimberly Akimbo" at the Booth, "Operation Mincemenat" at the Golden, "Maybe Happy Ending" at the Belasco)-- "Button" could do the same and it has title recognition.

In contrast is "The Heart" which I admired...superb production design, smartly staged, a powerful story. But the subject matter- well, it's not a family show, it's not a date show, and its storytelling is tough for an older audience. I understand it's moving to Broadway, but that's a bold and highly risky venture.

#67

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

Just got home. I had high hopes but my ears felt assaulted. Why all the damn yelling? I was in row c and thought perhaps the individuals in the ensemble needed to make sure the back row could hear all the narration? It got old fast. And I hate narration especially when they all have to keep repeating things like “it’s been 378 days and 18 minutes and 48 second since…”

I thought Kimmel was good and I liked her two songs. The rest of the music all sounds the same and I would not want to hear it again. I’m disappointed since I had been looking forward to this one. I wish it well but I won’t be revisiting it if it transfers. Just not for me.

#69

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

Saw this show last night, having looked forward to it for many months. It is a sweet and gentle piece, though not for me as affecting as I'd imagined. I also felt a sameness to the score and an overselling by the ensemble from the 4th row - possibly it might not seem so in a larger theater. I'm a fan of Andrew Durand, but felt he had limited opportunities in this central role, somehow. Kelsee Kimmel was lovely as the love of his life. Some strong moments, but a bit of a miss for me...
#70

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

I found this to be an excellent production and the central relationship between Benjamin and Elowen to be one of the strongest theatrical romances in recent memory. I usually agree with Sara Holdren, but her review reads overly cynical/nitpicky in my opinion.

Kelsee Kimmel is unreal.

Updated On: 11/14/26 at 03:01 PM

#71

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

Many good ingredients here, but they don't coalesce as well as they should. If it does move to Broadway, I hope it gets some advance doctoring because the potential for a more involving experience is there.

#72

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)


I’m not sure if this survives in a larger Bway house, and certainly won’t give Paddington or Warriors any competition at Tony time."

I find these kind of comments increasingly hilarious when it comes to Warriors. We have ZERO indication that it will be any good at this point. All we have is a concept album (which I personally could barely get through once)... there's been no out of town try-out or anything that audiences or critics have seen of the show and yet so many people on this board are absolutely convinced it will be a Tony front-runner based solely on Lin's involvement. With Paddington and Button, we have 2 Olivier Award winning musicals that have both received some very glowing reviews from critics. The same is true of The Heart, which may also transfer this season. Maybe we should all just wait and see how Warriors is once it starts previews.

#74

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

I liked this a lot today. I think it's too long, but I enjoyed it. Thought the performances terrific, score quite lovely (though repetitive at times) and I was really moved to see Durand growing more and more into a mature actor.

if this transfers, I pray they fix the sound design. I was front row and really struggled to make out the lyrics for the sections where everything happens in town to change fate (there are three of these, and all three were a struggle for me).


"I know now that theatre saved my life." - Susan Stroman
#75

Re: THE CURIOUS CASE OF BENJAMIN BUTTON reviews (Off-Broadway)

I saw yesterday's matinee. I found this to be a mostly charming show that I think might appeal to fans of Hadestown. Other parts, like how the cast played so many different little roles reminded me of Operation Mincemeat. I don't like to sit close, so I was further back and the sound was good for me.
The story took a few dark turns I wasn't prepared for, but on the whole it has a sweet life affirming message. I went in without having listened to any recordings, and found the music charming. I get what people say about it being all very samey. But there are a couple songs that are quite good on their own. I look forward to hearing the score again. My only complaint might be that with all the recorder or whistle music it sounded a lot like the music from the movie Titanic.

I think this is a grower and not a shower.


One caveat - on the way out of the theater, a woman ahead of me turned to her husband and said in the the thickest, most guttural, most incomprehensible New York accent, " I cuuuudn't understa a wrrrrd thaaa sed." So the show may not have an easy time with the audiences of New York.


...

Latest Posts

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71