"Besty, you have stated that T Wizard of Oz was in no way political. I do respect your opinion on the fact .However I question it when Mr Baum did in fact opine on political issues of the time."
First of all, I never stated that the Wizard of Oz was in no way political. Quite the opposite. I said he was absolutely influenced by the people and places around him, including his mother-in-law who was a famous suffragette. Please re-read my post before you misquote me or misrepresent my opinion.
And it is just that, an opinion. I added that I discussed the recent editorials claiming all of these hidden political and economic meanings in The Wizard of Oz with two of his great-grandsons, and they refuted it as well, saying basically what I said. He was more influenced by the people and places around him than any hidden political agendas about the Emerald City representing capitalism and the Yellow Brick Road representing the gold standard, etc.
As far as his editorial while he was running a newspaper out in the "wild west," this was years before he moved to Chicago and wrote The Wizard of Oz. He held the unfortunate opinion of many white men who sought to repress and even "eliminate" the Native Americans to preserve their own race. I don't approve of that at all, but I also don't mix it up with his later writings in a children's book. Baum spoke plainly. His writing was always direct and economical. He said what was on his mind. If he wanted to write a political piece, he did so, and if he wanted to write a children's book, he did so. And yes, sometimes his political thoughts and opinions entered into this children's stories, but they did so in a direct way. No hidden meanings. He had an army of women attack and take over the Emerald City in his second Oz book ("The Marvelous Land of Oz"
armed with knitting needles as weapons. Of course, this "amusing" plot device was influenced by the strong women in his own household.
He also showed another ugly trait of his era: racism. Check out "Rinkitink in Oz" where he depicts the "Tottenhots" (clearly lampooning the Hottentots of Africa) and although they are savages with scarlet hair, he refers to them as a "lower form of man."
Baum was human, a man, and very definitely a product if his time, influenced by the people and places around him. My comments in the other post addressed him hiding subliminal meanings in everything from the Yellow Brick Road to the poppy field, etc. I don't believe that to be true. I do believe his writing was influenced in a far more direct way by the people, places, and events of his era.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Updated On: 12/12/15 at 07:25 AM