I just got home. It definitely felt like a first preview- tons of set glitches, pacing issues, DICTION- but if there's anyone who can fix this stuff it's Bartlett Sher.
I hate to start off with such a negative, but since it stuck out like such a sore thumb, Watanabe's diction was at times atrocious. Thank god we all know the words to A Puzzlement or it would have been five minutes of watching a Polish movie without subtitles. There would be lines/exchanges where is diction would come into focus and he'd get a laugh or required reaction, but other times words at the end of sentences would be swallowed or thrown away. It didn't ruin the evening, but it certainly threw things off at times. I will say I think his acting is there- we just need to understand the words or it won't work.
To balance all this out was the stunning performance from Kelli. She could do no wrong tonight. Even the Hello, Young Lovers reprise turned into a showstopper. Getting to Know You was delightful (everything with the kids played well), and she had a nice rapport with Watanabe in the dialogue before the temple scene and surrounding Shall We Dance. Kelli is the anchor holding down the show and is turning in yet more splendid work.
Ruthie Ann Miles added a lot of depth to Lady Thiang. The character is younger and more vibrant than usual. Something Wonderful (one of my favorite theater songs ever) was beautiful.
Ashley Park has a crystal clear soprano and sings Tuptim with lovely passion. Lun Tha really is an underwritten role, but he's played by hottie Conrad Ricamora (Oliver from HTGAWM!!!). And he's bare chested whenever on stage so can't really complain there.
The physical production is sometimes breathtaking. The sets, lighting, costumes- all the first rate quality we have come to expect from LCT. Catherine Zuber can probably make some more room on her mantel after her showing tonight.
The ballet was a highlight; much of the original choreography was used or was at least inspired by Robbins' work.
The show is already in good shape, but in time I think it grow into something special. I look forward to seeing it later in previews.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!