Saw this in Pittsburgh this past weekend, and sad to say that this production is going to be absolutely *crucified* by Broadway critics if it moves in its current state. That said, I still had a great time. The show and score are as infectious as ever, and it has truly never been sung better than by this cast.
The good:
Nichelle Lewis is a real find, and her vocals were insane. She needs to grow into the acting a bit more, but I bet she settles in well before it comes to New York.
Melody A. Betts completely brought the house down with both "The Feeling We Once Had" and "No Bad News"...the latter got the biggest reaction of the afternoon, along with "Be A Lion". She is the strongest actor in the company and feels very seasoned as compared to the rest.
Phillip Johnson Richardson is an incredible Tinman, a true triple threat. He was easily my favorite of Dorothy's friends. "What Would I Do If I Could Feel?" was a real showstopper.
Kyle Ramar Freeman is an appropriately flouncy and big-voiced Lion. Some of the Lion's new jokes are very funny.
Alan Mingo Jr. is a sly and well-sung Wiz. He felt a little RuPaul, which was rather appropriate. "Y'all Got It!" was cute and well staged.
The OK:
Deborah Cox has VERY lovely vocal moments but it's clear the team has no interest in (or rather, a palpable fear of) giving her any more than ten lines to speak. It's very odd to watch Addaperle (a lovely Allyson Kaye Daniel in what is now a featured ensemble position) lead both the scene that goes into "He's the Wiz" and the scene that goes into "Believe in Yourself" but not actually sing the songs. The scene that goes into "Believe in Yourself" needs a rewrite to tie the song into the stakes of the moment. And overall, as lovely as Allyson Kaye Daniel is, they need to try to trust Deborah to lead those scenes. Otherwise it just feels weird.
Avery Wilson is an amazing singer and dancer, but some of his scene work really needs improvement. It felt very presentational.
Amber Ruffin's new book is much smarter and a definite improvement in many ways, but it's a little overwritten, and honestly - this cast is full of singers and dancers above actors - some scenes were absolutely painful. And even if they weren't painful, they were all mostly VERY long. She needs to trim the fat so we can get to what works the best faster - the incredible score. the show does not move at a consistent rhythm, and there are odd choices to include old songs that halt the momentum like a dropped anvil (like "Wonder Wonder Why") that were cut initially for a reason.
The choreography works occasionally (the Emerald City sequence is awesome, as is the choreo in "You Can't Win" and many other character-specific songs), and other times, you're like...what is happening? ("Poppies", "Everybody Rejoice"). Same with the costumes. Some look opulent (the principals all look great) and others cheap (manyensemble looks are very unfinished).
the bad:
The sets are very, very cheap looking. "Built to tour" is one thing, but I just saw the tour of COMPANY, also a lower tier tour, and it looked classy and expensive. This, at times, looks like a high school set from up close. Evilene's tower looks very cheap from both sides, as does the Wiz's stage and throne, and they are among the largest set pieces. the projections are actually the best parts of the design.
So, this needs work. I hope when Wayne Brady comes in to rehearse they take the time to spruce things up a bit. All negative things aside, I really did have fun, and hope to catch it again before it moves to Broadway.