Hi Medtron,
Scott from the Gold Club here. I don't think you're asking too much at all!
We update the site throughout the day. If you were to check in 3 times, morning, noon, and early evening, you are most likely going to see different choices- and we encourage that.
Broadway, of course, is always the icing on the cake. Send an email to goldclub@theatermania.com and we'll give you a couple of member-only tricks on how to guarantee you'll get a pair of whatever Broadway the Gold Club has the next time it appears in the club.
Look forward to hearing from you!
Scott