The Winter Garden because of it's excellent sight lines and it's opulence. The last show that I saw there was in 1980 whn the original production of 42ND STREET played there. This beautiful theatre was totally refurbished for the occasion. I have stayed away from the Winter Garden ever since because I have had no desire to see either CATS or MAMA MIA. These long running shows are ruining the opportunity to attend this unique theatre with a grand hIstory. It is there that I saw my first Broadway show in 1954: PETER PAN wih Mary Martin. Other shows that I loved there include THE UNSINKABLE MOLLY BROWN with Tammy Grimes, the original producion of WEST SIDE STORY, FUNNY GIRL with a young Barbra Streisand, and MAME wih the one and only Ann Miller.
The Shubert is a beautiful theatre also with excellent sight lines, in the heart of the Theatre Diistrict. One can see perfectly from the first row of the second balcony, which is where I usually sit. I have probably seen more shows at this Flagship theatre of the Shubert Organization and that is why I choose the Sam S. Shubert as one of the theaters I would like to own. I love the wood beams on the underside of the first balcony , the murals on the walls and ceiling, and the proscenium and house curtain (does anyone remember that all Broadway theaters have house curtains-- now when you enter a theatre all you see is the show curtain). Shows that I have enjoyed there include TAKE ME ALONG(1959) co- starring Jackie Gleason, I CAN GET IT FOR YOU WHOLESALE(1962) where Barbra Streisand made her Broadway debut, STOP THE WORLD--I WANT TO GET OFF (1962) with Anthony NEWLEY (I hated it), THE ROAR OF THE GREASEPAINT--THE SMELL OF THE CROWD(1965) also wih Anthony Newley( I loved it), HERE'S LOVE(1963)-- a bomb,THE APPLE TREE (1966) with Barbara Harris and Alan Alda, PROMISES,PROMISES (1969), OVER HERE!(1974) including John Travolta, A CHORUS LINE (1975) 4 times, CRAZY FOR YOU(1992) 4 times with an under appreciated Harry Groener, GYPSY(2003) directed by Sam Mendes--my least favorite production of this greatest of musicals.
"Madam Rose...and her daughter...Gypsy!"