Broadway Star Joined: 1/21/20
Broadway Legend Joined: 2/14/20
Dear Broadway,
Please, I beg, do not turn every movie into a stage production, and not every stage show into a movie.
Thx!
Make it stop.
Yes, please. I’d love to pay $200 to see not Lady Gaga or Bradley Cooper sing those great songs that Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper performed so well that I can listen to or watch anytime I want to for zero dollars.
Much like GATSBY, it’s a tale as old as time and song as old as rhyme.
Unless there is a radical reimagining of this otherwise basic story, leave it alone.
Id rather see the Judy Garland one as a musical. It seems perfect for the stage. The Lady Gaga one was like a rock concert.
Jordan Catalano said: "Yes, please. I’d love to pay $200 to see not Lady Gaga or Bradley Cooper sing those great songs that Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper performed so well that I can listen to or watch anytime I want to for zero dollars."
This.
I adore the Cooper/Gaga ASIB, but that thing only has juice because of their work on screen in it.
quizking101 said: "Much like GATSBY, it’s a tale as old as time and song as old as rhyme.
Unless there is a radical reimagining of this otherwise basic story, leave it alone."
This adaptation is based on the 2018 Cooper/Gaga film version of the story - it's not a reimagining of the A STAR IS BORN franchise.
BrodyFosse123 said: "quizking101 said: "Much like GATSBY, it’s a tale as old as time and song as old as rhyme.
Unless there is a radical reimagining of this otherwise basic story, leave it alone."
This adaptation is based on the 2018 Cooper/Gaga film version of the story - it's not a reimagining of the A STAR IS BORN franchise."
That was their point, dear.
A stage adaptation based on the older movies was already in the works as late as 2017 - until Cooper’s version came and changed everything when it proved to be a box office success.
Depending on how this is eventually received, this could be an interesting “what if” to look back on.
Considering the source (Roger Friedman), this could be nothing.
Might work better to have some sort of non-union live touring or cruise ship show using the songs & clips from the movie alongside dancers and a live band.
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/11/16
I wouldn't be opposed to a musical adaptation of the original story. There's been four versions of this movie now, all of which, to some extent, have tried to do their own thing with it (1937 and 1954 were about film actors, 1976 was about rock stars, 2018 was about country stars). Why not a version where the two leads are musical theatre performers?
Leading Actor Joined: 6/14/22
How about they do a version where the girl is a talented USO singer and the guy is an Artie Shaw-type jazz man?
Wait...
Back in 2017 it was announced that Bill Condon would be directing a stage version of the Judy Garland film.
https://playbill.com/article/a-star-is-born-is-heading-to-the-stage
It's somewhat surprising that no one has done it before. My favorite is the Gaynor version.
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/27/19
At this point they should do it as a reincarnation or time travel story about two people/souls stuck reliving the same story over and over in different eras. That way they can use all the songs from the various versions. Make the fact that audiences are seeing this story yet again part of the premise.
I don't think I'd be excited for a stage adaptation of the Garland one, but it would kind of make sense.
I cannot fathom wanting to see the Gaga one onstage without the performers. There's like...nothing else to that movie, or those songs.
MemorableUserName said: "At this point they should do it as a reincarnation or time travel story about two people/souls stuck reliving the same story over and over in different eras. That way they can use all the songs from the various versions. Make the fact that audiences are seeing this story yet again part of the premise."
Omigod! I thought of the same thing, and was coming to post that.
This sounds like the psychological horror comic “Love Everlasting,” which is like Westworld for romance tropes instead of cyberpunk.
Leading Actor Joined: 6/14/22
I got it:
A hip-hop version where the Bradley Cooper character is now a closeted rapper who peaked in the early nineties and the Lady Gaga role is a more openly gay rapper like Lil Naz X or Ice Spice. Controversy and self-destruction ensue.
verywellthensigh said: "I got it:
A hip-hop version where the Bradley Cooper character is now a closeted rapper who peaked in the early nineties and the Lady Gaga role is a more openly gay rapper like Lil Naz X or Ice Spice. Controversy and self-destruction ensue."
Not bad.
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/29/13
They will be adding Gaga's biggest pop hits to the score too...like Alicia Key's musical.
Videos