Posted: 10/31/22 at 7:24am
JBroadway said: "I spoke positively about the show when I saw it in early-ish previews. I wrote a posted saying it fell "just under" my high expectations, and saying that John David Washington had the MAKINGS of a powerhouse performance, but needed to time to find more variation in the performance.
I have to confess I've cooled on the production a little bit, in the last month or so. And I'm disappointed to read from these reviews that the production's rough edges weren't honed during previews. I think I was more forgiving of the production because all of the issues seemed like they were totally fixable: the actors just needed time to settle in, and the director just needed time to find the rhythm of the play as a whole. But the fact that some reviewers are pointing out some of the same uneasiness I saw in previews, is a little disheartening.
As for John David Washington's performance; I maintain that he has a potent stage presence, with a natural charisma, and a strong sense of who this character is. But I'll admit I've cooled off on his performance a bit too; the issues with the performance have nagged at me more than I expected, especially hearing some other people's criticisms of it, and realizing I agree. Again, it's disheartening to hear that he hasn't settled into the rhythm of the play over the course of previews."
I saw this yesterday and I thought Washington was incredible. I - and the other three people I was with - all thought the entire production was one of the best we have seen, with some of the best acting we have seen. Having seeing Leopoldstant last weekend and now The Piano Lesson, I feel like Broadway is doing what Broadway does best - entertains while making us think and helps us learn. The Piano Lesson definitely did that yesterday and I am thankful.
The only less than stellar part of the show was the very ending, which I think others have mentioned. I didn’t love how the director tackled the very last scene BUT it did not detract from the overall experience.
Highly recommend this show.
Oh, and there was a lot of verbal audience reaction and I loved it. To me, it was a visceral reaction to the action and the words and it highlighted the connection the audience had to the show.