Saw this show last night. Mostly enjoyed it. Don't know anything by Joe Iconis, and song were catchy and well-arranged. But could I hum you a number from the show? Not at all. And that first act closer goes on way too long, I started dozing off. But some good performances overall and a strong book. I honestly haven't a clue how it'll do come awards season.
I will say it was definitely a different audience last night than the usual Broadway crowd, but for the most part they were definitely digging the show, cheered loudly but respectfully, and didn't see any phone lights. One kid was in a tux with a red bowtie saying it was the best thing he ever saw, and that was a really sweet thing to see.
"Hey little girls, look at all the men in shiny shirts and no wives!" - Jackie Hoffman, Xanadu, 19 Feb 2008