Beanie’s Last Performance 9/25- Page 4

[joevitus]

Posted: 6/16/22 at 6:50pm

RippedMan said: "OhHiii said: "RippedMan said: "Two seasoned musical theater performers with Tonys are the same as Beanie? Okay...."

Beanie has been in several very popular, critically acclaimed films. Headlined a Ryan Murphy series opposite of Sarah Paulson. And also has a well-reviewed Broadway turn under her belt in one of the biggest hit musicals to come to Broadway in the last decade? Yeah. I'd say it would be completely understandable why she'd get an offer without an audition.

For the record, she has said she auditioned, but keep dying on this hill, bud.

https://youtu.be/eyJ6iUownnk?t=204


Cool. Not dying on any hill. I literally don't really care. Just having a discussion. She's proven she doesn't have the stamina for 8x a week as a lead performer, nor does she have the vocal chops for the role or the acting requirements given all the reviews. Patti Lupone and Hugh Jackman have actually proven they have what it takes before hand. A character part in a hit show doesn't mean you can handle 8x a week as a lead.

"

She's shown she doesn't have the stamina for this role, maybe. But the Funny Girl score is nearly all Fanny, and tailored to the strength of a uniquely powerful voice. That Beanie can't fill that demand, and surely isn't right for Eva Peron or Mama Rose, doesn't mean she can't lead an evening's entertainment. When she's age appropriate, she'll probably make a great Dolly. She might make a good Miss Mona now. She's too old for Tracy Turnblad, but a younger her would have probably been terrific in the role. I think there are a lot of parts she can play, even leading roles. But she needs something not as vocally demanding as Fanny Brice.

[Dylan Pellagrino]

Posted: 6/16/22 at 7:24pm

ErmengardeStopSniveling said: "Dylan Pellagrino said: "she was at the Tonys last weekend…. And Beanie was not."

Are you dim, or do you just enjoy making up bogus justifications for no reason?

1) Lea was part of a group performance with the cast of SPRING AWAKENING.

2) Beanie had COVID."

As far as I am aware, the show was only nominated for one Tony award (for featured actor) so I don’t think she would be there anyway. I looked online and couldn’t find any pictures of the cast attending except Jared Grimes.
& You’re right Lea is part of the spring awakening cast, but they also had her come out and speak before the performance. Which was definitely a choice. 

[Dollypop]

Posted: 6/16/22 at 7:37pm

Beanie should try her hand at Aldonza in MAN OF LA MANCHA

[Highland Guy]

Posted: 6/16/22 at 8:12pm

Robbie2 said: "
"

Yes, please!  Lea as Fanny would likely bring me back to Broadway from the West Coast for the first time since pre-pandemic.  She is the perfect star to play a star.

[PipingHotPiccolo]

Posted: 6/16/22 at 8:17pm

RippedMan said: "Can't speak for everyone, but for me, it was the fact that she has had a "leg up" in this industry and comes from a wealthy family. And the fact that it's been proven that there are more talented, better suited for the show performers, that this just feels like the world gets it."

I appreciate this comment so much because its honest, does away with the "im just saying i dont like her singing" nonsense, and is so dark and weird. You're mad she got a leg up, as opposed to....who exactly? Pick a show trying to capitalize on celebrity and tell me the lead/star/whatever didnt get a leg up. And yet with her, from the OUTSET, the knives were out that she... didnt really deserve the shot, that she didnt have to audition (a lie), that this was all a project organized by her uber powerful parents (that no one has ever heard of), now we have this steady stream of sh*t about her not really having Covid, about her missing the Tonys (she was there), etc etc.

 

And it all stems from this odd, almost jealous undercurrent of "how dare she!" Is it because shes chubby? Is it because shes so young to be grabbing these opportunities? Beanie didnt get where she is by doing anything other than... succeeding at making a name for herself. And not by banging a guy on a home movie, or screaming at women in a restaurant on a reality show, but by turning in solid likeable performances in pretty well received films. Why is Pam Anderson welcomed with open arms, when she has no singing ability, no dancing ability, just gumption, but Beanie is a disaster with a lifelong love of theater dying to do this show? RippedMan's comment is so telling.

Something about Beanie, as opposed to [everyone else] just gets under peoples skin and unreasonably so. I thought Lynch was just great but was she BEST POSSIBLE ACTRESS FOR THE ROLE, or was she someone who made a name for herself and they're capitalizing on it? Would you rather these "stars" stay away from the theater so these shows cant get capitalized at all? 

Get.A.Grip.

[Sutton Ross]

Posted: 6/16/22 at 8:58pm

After three long rambling posts, I don't think we're the ones that need to get a grip.

 

[SouthernCakes]

Posted: 6/16/22 at 9:12pm

PipingHotPiccolo said: "RippedMan said: "Can't speak for everyone, but for me, it was the fact that she has had a "leg up" in this industry and comes from a wealthy family. And the fact that it's been proven that there are more talented, better suited for the show performers, that this just feels like the world gets it."

I appreciate this comment so much because its honest, does away with the "im just saying i dont like her singing" nonsense, and is so dark and weird. You're mad she got a leg up, as opposed to....who exactly? Pick a show trying to capitalize on celebrity and tell me the lead/star/whatever didnt get a leg up. And yet with her, from the OUTSET, the knives were out that she... didnt really deserve the shot, that she didnt have to audition (a lie), that this was all a project organized by her uber powerful parents (that no one has ever heard of), now we have this steady stream of sh*t about her not really having Covid, about her missing the Tonys (she was there), etc etc.



And it all stems from this odd, almost jealous undercurrent of "how dare she!" Is it because shes chubby? Is it because shes so young to be grabbing these opportunities? Beanie didnt get where she is by doing anything other than... succeeding at making a name for herself. And not by banging a guy on a home movie, or screaming at women in a restaurant on a reality show, but by turning in solid likeable performances in pretty well received films. Why is Pam Anderson welcomed with open arms, when she has no singing ability, no dancing ability, just gumption, but Beanie is a disaster with a lifelong love of theater dying to do this show? RippedMan's comment is so telling.

Something about Beanie, as opposed to [everyone else] just gets under peoples skin and unreasonably so. I thought Lynch was just great but was she BEST POSSIBLE ACTRESS FOR THE ROLE, or was she someone who made a name for herself and they're capitalizing on it? Would you rather these "stars" stay away from the theater so these shows cant get capitalized at all?

Get.A.Grip."

Lol no one has mentioned her weight. We are upset because she’s wrong for the role. And that’s been proven. So peace. 

[Auggie27]

Posted: 6/16/22 at 9:29pm

I saw her two weeks ago, and felt the projected need to root for her. The way you do watching a stock production wherein a TV personality takes on a stage role with forethought, skill, and above all else, good intentions. I wasn't troubled by her singing per se, which has nice notes - “Who Are You Now?” - some power moments  - “Parade” - aided by the soundboard. I felt I was being asked to buy into the conceptual fact of her casting, her performance in this venue, Broadway. So I kept leaning forward with that "is this the moment when she seals the deal?" expectation. In other words, I didn't sit in the dark house, hands across my chest, waiting for failure. I waited to be surprised. Sincerely.

When the performance's workmanlike okay-ness coasted on -- marred by Mayer encouraging some unappealing clowning (that roll downstage in an ill-chosen costume) -- the show's seams showed, the second act's structural monotony and reliance on snippets of reprises to cue emotions sinking it.
 
Feldstein's problem is that she can't deliver this vehicle as a vehicle. And once that becomes clear, the whole endeavor charging premium prices begins to implode. This star is never "bad" or embarrassing, moments of clowning excesses aside. But she can't make a case for Funny Girl to be happening. That, to me, is the fundamental problem baked into the DNA of this revival.

Updated On: 6/16/22 at 09:29 PM

[SouthernCakes]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 12:03am

Auggie27 said: "I saw her two weeks ago, and felt the projected need to root for her. The way you do watching a stock production wherein a TV personality takes on a stage role with forethought, skill, and above all else, good intentions. I wasn't troubled by her singing per se, which has nice notes - “Who Are You Now?” - some power moments - “Parade” - aided by the soundboard. I felt I was being asked to buy into the conceptual fact of her casting, her performance in this venue, Broadway. So I kept leaning forward with that "is this the moment when she seals the deal?" expectation. In other words, I didn't sit in the dark house, hands across my chest, waiting for failure. I waited to be surprised. Sincerely.

When the performance's workmanlike okay-ness coasted on -- marred by Mayer encouraging some unappealing clowning (that roll downstage in an ill-chosen costume) -- the show's seams showed, the second act's structural monotony and reliance on snippets of reprises to cue emotions sinking it.

Feldstein's problem is that she can't deliver this vehicle as a vehicle. And once that becomes clear, the whole endeavor charging premium prices begins to implode. This star is never "bad" or embarrassing, moments of clowning excesses aside. But she can't make a case for Funny Girl to be happening. That, to me, is the fundamental problem baked into the DNA of this revival."

Perfectly said! I think the anger is that we all knew on paper she was not the right fit for the role and how the producers and director didn’t know is baffling. 

[jonartdesigns]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 10:59am

If she’s been mentioned already, my apologies. Ariana DeBose would be inspired casting. 

[Bettyboy72]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 3:22pm

SouthernCakes said" Perfectly said! I think the anger is that we all knew on paper she was not the right fit for the role and how the producers and director didn’t know is baffling."

I do wonder, in the production's defense, if she was a smart choice from whatever audition process or creative process was involved in her casting. In all honesty, you never really know how any actor is going to fare in a role until its on its legs and possibly too late to change. And every promising star actor had a production that took a chance on them to deliver a lead performance. For many, they deliver and become bigger stars.

Beanie is clearly a dynamic talent who can sing. She can do comedy and is really likeable. She's been a sweet media "it" girl for a while now. She appeared eager to challenge herself and take on the role. There are great "bones" to work with. Maybe the creative team pinned their hopes on greater gains based on her talent, drive and commitment. Those hopes never materialized. Even with all her hard work, committed actions and kindness to the company, she was never able to deliver the "star" performance to sell this vehicle. If she had it would have truly been a happening and a revelation. That is what is so sad about it-it tanked the production. 

But I imagine the producers had great faith her in abilities and their ability to meld them. 

 

[Popular]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 3:45pm

So we’re just ignoring the fact that Paul Wontorek tweeted out gossip before any official announcement was made? Kind of tacky, he should know better. I’ll expect this post to be deleted by the mods in 3,2,1…

[BroadwayGirl107]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 4:37pm

Popular said: "So we’re just ignoring the fact that Paul Wontorek tweeted out gossip before any official announcement was made? Kind of tacky, he should know better. I’ll expect this post to be deleted by the mods in 3,2,1…"

That’s why I think there’s no way Lea is actually taking over. He’d burn so many bridges by doing that.

 

There’s no credible source behind the Michele rumor. Just a lot of people who think it’s a funny idea and wanting to believe it’s true. 

[Popular]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 4:49pm

BroadwayGirl107 said: "Popular said: "So we’re just ignoring the fact that Paul Wontorek tweeted out gossip before any official announcement was made? Kind of tacky, he should know better. I’ll expect this post to be deleted by the mods in 3,2,1…"

That’s why I think there’s no way Lea is actually taking over. He’d burn so many bridges by doing that.



There’s no credible source behind the Michele rumor. Just a lot of people who think it’s a funny idea and wanting to believe it’s true."

Tacky either way to be participating in the gossip being in his positions. I don’t see the humor, there are real people and feelings being what we see as just fun speculation. I made my own “wish list” for Jane’s replacement but that was already a planned exit with little talk surrounding it.

[BroadwayGirl107]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 5:22pm

“

Tacky either way to be participating in the gossip being in his positions. I don’t see the humor, there are real people and feelings being what we see as just fun speculation. I made my own “wish list” for Jane’s replacement but that was already a planned exit with little talk surrounding it."

 

Literally WHAT are you talking about? Whose feelings is he hurting? I also didn’t take his post as gossip or a rumor…just that he’d like to see Lea Michele take over. There is literally no malice or gossip in that…everyone else is projecting that onto it because they’re just so hungry for an actual rumor.

 

[Kad]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 5:31pm

Y’all are wild with this.

There is no weight to any social media-generated gossip about Lea, or anybody else, taking over this role. 


There is no harm in speculating or expressing hope in who will take over for Beanie. We have her exit date, it’s entirely fine to wonder what comes after. 

[ErmengardeStopSniveling]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 5:31pm

Don't know if this article from Roger Friedman has already been mentioned but WTF is he talking about? I know he's the king of bad gossip but this is REALLY grasping at straws.

"This past Sunday, Lea Michele was a hit on the Tony Awards during the “Spring Awakening” reunion. She was really given the spotlight, and hit a home run. The Tonys appearance was either because her deal was already done, or because producers were waiting to see how Michele would be received. It was all ‘thumbs up.’"

A hit? She was part of a group performance! She also said a couple of words from a teleprompter! She was fine!

[Popular]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 5:47pm

Speculation is fine and human nature. It comes off different when it’s done by someone of Paul’s positions and status within the Broadway community. I stand by my OPINION that it’s in poor taste, and maybe hurtful, coming from him specifically. I have made no comment of other people speculating. 

[inception]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 5:48pm

I thought the people who showed the most class were folks like Cynthia Erivo and Lena Waite sitting front row center, and they didn't get up and claw out the eyes of a known white supremacist. 

[RippedMan]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 6:06pm

Lordy. 

Anyway, I mean, both are directed by Mayer, so there's a connection there. And it is interesting that she opened when Groff is arguably the more famous of the two now. So that's interesting. 

[Auggie27]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 6:37pm

Twitter has this idea that the star has been “chased out” of the role. Reality check: September 25th isn't exactly next week, or next month. 14 weeks is a long "chase" out of a production. For many stars, that’s an entire contractual commitment.

From some responses in social media, it sounds as if she's been forced to give her last handful of performances. An entire summer of Feldstein Fannys await anyone who wishes to attend, and in this still challenging Broadway season, an entire summer isn't exactly a short run. 

Updated On: 6/17/22 at 06:37 PM

[Sally Durant Plummer]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 7:00pm

Mods are real delete happy, aren't they?

[Kad]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 8:21pm

Popular said: "Speculation is fine and human nature. It comes off different when it’s done by someone of Paul’s positions and status within the Broadway community. I stand by my OPINION that it’s in poor taste, and maybe hurtful, coming from him specifically. I have made no comment of other people speculating."

He runs Broadway.com- he’s hardly someone who needs to conceal his opinions on who he’d like to see take over a role when an actor has announced their departure. It’s not like he called Feldstein untalented.

Updated On: 6/17/22 at 08:21 PM

[Jordan Catalano]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 8:34pm

Sally Durant Plummer said: "Mods are real delete happy, aren't they?"

For a few days now they’ve quickly been deleting comments that are simply speculative of replacement casting and not breaking any sort of rule whatsoever. It’s been very odd to follow. 

[RippedMan]

Posted: 6/17/22 at 8:36pm

Honestly I'm not seeing a lot of hate for Leah Michele on Twitter. People seem super into it.