This is a really strange, interesting case study in putting on a Broadway show.
On one hand, the timing was perfect: started previews on the heels of a new season of HACKS and leading up to Emmy season, and was Smart's first Broadway appearance in 25 years.
On the other hand, the timing was bad: it was the most star-filled spring season on Broadway in years - and as far as Broadway buzz goes, all attention was on the new shows with bigger stars.
It's always interesting when a Broadway show opens on the heels of a huge TV show or awards campaign. Sometimes they sell (Bryan Cranston as LBJ on the heels of Breaking Bad) and sometimes they don't (Brian Cox as LBJ at peak Succession hype, Elisabeth Moss in Heidi Chronicles on the heels of Mad Men, Laurie Metcalf in Doll's House on the heels of Lady Bird).
And then there some actors who return to the stage time and again but are rarely ever moneymaking stars. Metcalf, Allison Janney, John Lithgow, Laura Linney, Mary-Louise Parker, Nathan Lane without an equally-famous costar...etc. When Adrian Brody makes his Broadway debut later this season, I wonder if he'll be in that camp too.
I love Jean Smart. I get why she wanted to do something totally different from a scenery-chewing dark comedy. But this was a poor vehicle for her. Let's hope she returns to the stage again soon under better circumstances and with an equally-meaningful costar.
Updated On: 7/10/25 at 10:35 AM