Biggest difference between the older shows and now are ticket prices. Before prices exploded, people might be willing to take a shot on a show with bad word of mouth during previews. Now people may not want to shell out 2 c notes for something that is being trashed all over the place. Some of the shows mentioned were trying out on the road and were not in the bullseye known as New York City.
"Aside from An American in Paris, with which I would disagree, those are all shows from a very different Broadway, though."
What do you mean by a very different Broadway?... not picking a fight just genuinely curious. A different style of show than China Doll, a different era, a more forgiving audience, a pre-Internet age? Even aside from this specific show, and whether it improves or not, I guess I just have to believe in the power of something to get stronger, whether significantly or even just incrementally. I agree that it's very rare that shows improve in a meaningful way from how they appear straight out of the gate... but it does happen, it's happened before, and whether with this show or not, it will happen again.
"Discussion of the play aside, the notion people are actually saying previews don't exist and a show should be ready on the first public performance is not only insane, it just betrays your lack of experience."
So whether at an out-of-town tryout or a first preview, there is not a minimum degree of competence in any domain that a paying customer has the right to expect. Such as a Tony-Award-winning actor with stage experience spanning fifty years actually projecting his voice in such a way as to make himself heard by the audience. How dare anyone expect or demand that! How "insane," and how revealing of one's "lack of experience!"
"If this is indeed sold out, they would probably be selling standing room until word of mouth spreads."
Generally shows in previews don't sell standing room. However,this show is selling standing room for the spots in house left (the center is being used by the production for the time being). I believe the tickets for standing room are $67.
"Fosse76 said: "I believe the tickets for standing room are $67."
Is that setting a new high for SRO?"
That seems ridiculously high for standing room. Even the revival of Glengarry with Pacino, which I am under the impression sold much better prior to opening than China Doll, had SRO for less than $40.
I saw the play today and came to this message board because I was curious what others thought. I thought it was very interesting. I was actually considering seeing at a second time (but only if I could find a cheap ticket.)
I have not read every single comment but I got the gist. Those that saw it weren't that impressed. Those that didn't are now not going to. I wish that weren't the case. If you were intending to see it you should still consider going. I know tickets aren't cheaper because its a preview but there's a reason that critics aren't permitted to write reviews now. It takes the actors a while to find the play and really get comfortable with a script. Sometimes the first preview is only the first or second time that a play has been run through from start to finish. Now compound that with a play which is almost (but not quite) a monologue then you really have to give them a little time to work out the kinks.
I loved Pacino in the film of Glengary Glenn Ross and I loved him in the Phil Spector movie. The guy knows how to do Mamet. You have to give him a little time to get comfy with it.
I absolutely promise that I'm not affiliated with the show in any way. I saw that there is a person who is working on the show in some capacity. I really just wanted to hear what others had to say about it.
And you're right...an Al Pacino play that is sold out doesn't need a shill up at 12:30am to talk about a play.
I wasn't even necessarily intend to post something but when I saw how rough some of the comments were, I thought I'd give my two cents.
Just read Riedel's column on it. This is shaping up as a disaster on a scale of the Titanic. This sounds like one of those disasters people want to see like viewing an accident.
Mamet may become a word worse than Wildhorn. Stay tuned kiddies.
If curious it might be wise to wait until is available in print at The Drama Book Shop. You can always peruse it there, They supply an assortment of chairs for that purpose. That's how I saved myself from seeing The Anarchist. P.S. You should buy something else when you're there. This is one great little shop that can never be replaced.
Had no intention of seeing it prior to the horror stories. Have less than no interest of seeing it or reading it now. I feel sorry for those who shelled out big bucks to see this train wreck. The reviews from the critics should be a barrel of laughs.