I saw this tonight, and first and foremost, BCfitasafiddle is not joking about the Playbill inserts with a QR code asking you to vote for the Broadway.com audience choice awards. Easily one of the tackiest things I have ever seen.
As for the show itself, what can I possibly say that hasn't already been said by the masses? It's a colossal failure on every level. What we have is an all around bad production of a bad show with a hummable score. The direction is stagnant (and to think I thought Jerry Zaks work was slightly uninspired at The Music Man last night...), the design is dark, dank, dingy, and cheap cheap cheap, and the less said about the performances, the better.
Beanie Feldstein is so incredibly wrong for Fanny in literally every way under the sun. I have to hand it Michael Mayer who has managed to singlehandedly deliver the three all-time most embarrassing stage performances I have seen - Taye is Hedwig, Tammy in Little Shop, and now Beanie in Funny Girl completes the trifecta as his "crowning jewel". Mayer has done some good work in the past, but his pattern of going with untraditional casting choices is just not working out.
"There’s nothing quite like the power and the passion of Broadway music. "