#351
Posted: 1/10/15 at 11:39pm
Saw the show tonight with a sold-out crowd. (Or at least close-to sold-out)
The audience was eating it up. At least everyone around me seemed to chuckle or laugh a few times and the orchestra got thunderous applause. The show is def. not without its flaws, but it's an enjoyable time.
There are two major problems I found: The show feels/looks like a regional show. The three main leads were all fine, even great in some cases, but their vocals were just lackluster or unexciting. I couldn't help but wonder what someone like Norbert Leo Butz and Sherie Rene Scott would have done with those roles back in the day. Rob was the best of the 3, but his vocals left me a little underwhelmed, I felt like the orchestra drowned him out most of the time.
The second problem is Tony Danza. By all means he's not horrible, but he sings a lot of ballads and his vocals are....tricky. He's shaky and you can feel the strain in his voice. I wish they had cast someone like Brian Stokes Mitchell. This suave guy with a silky voice. And his tap moment felt totally superfluous.
The score is pretty consistent. I really liked Jack/Betsy's songs the best. I think the first 20mins of the show are just really, really great. The opening song is pure Jason Robert Brown Last 5 Years. It's great. The mother's song is hilarious and Nancy Opel kills it. It's funny, surprising, entertaining. It's great. I can she'd choose this over On the Town. She stands out for sure. And then Betsy's song is pretty great. I just with her vocals had been up to par.
End the end it's not a bad show. I just can see why it's having a hard time catching on. The physical production looks kind of cheap. The direction is fine if a little underwhelming. The score is great but feels a little padded. Do we need a 5 min. singing elvis song?
I wish the show had been re-cast for Broadway. It could really use some vocal powerhouses in there or something.
The audience was eating it up. At least everyone around me seemed to chuckle or laugh a few times and the orchestra got thunderous applause. The show is def. not without its flaws, but it's an enjoyable time.
There are two major problems I found: The show feels/looks like a regional show. The three main leads were all fine, even great in some cases, but their vocals were just lackluster or unexciting. I couldn't help but wonder what someone like Norbert Leo Butz and Sherie Rene Scott would have done with those roles back in the day. Rob was the best of the 3, but his vocals left me a little underwhelmed, I felt like the orchestra drowned him out most of the time.
The second problem is Tony Danza. By all means he's not horrible, but he sings a lot of ballads and his vocals are....tricky. He's shaky and you can feel the strain in his voice. I wish they had cast someone like Brian Stokes Mitchell. This suave guy with a silky voice. And his tap moment felt totally superfluous.
The score is pretty consistent. I really liked Jack/Betsy's songs the best. I think the first 20mins of the show are just really, really great. The opening song is pure Jason Robert Brown Last 5 Years. It's great. The mother's song is hilarious and Nancy Opel kills it. It's funny, surprising, entertaining. It's great. I can she'd choose this over On the Town. She stands out for sure. And then Betsy's song is pretty great. I just with her vocals had been up to par.
End the end it's not a bad show. I just can see why it's having a hard time catching on. The physical production looks kind of cheap. The direction is fine if a little underwhelming. The score is great but feels a little padded. Do we need a 5 min. singing elvis song?
I wish the show had been re-cast for Broadway. It could really use some vocal powerhouses in there or something.