I’ll be watching due to the cast and early word. I don’t know the show particularly well and I’m not at all religious, so not sure if it will be for me but I’ll be giving it a shot!
It's so funny that folks keep saying (lots in the other thread) that they like it even though they're not religious, or don't know if it's for them because they're not religious. This is not a religious show, folks! This is the show that was denounced from the pulpit all over the country because Judas is the good guy and Jesus doesn't come back.
sbflyfan said: "Must the audience scream after every other line?"
Yeah, I like the staging and performances so far, but they’re getting swallowed up by the audience reaction. They need to tone it down a notch. It’s killing all the dramatic tension.
JCS is not seen as blasphemous, or even controversial in this day and age. It’s seen as a rock opera offering a different perspective of Jesus’ last week on earth.
Its a great show - and boasts one of the best rock score in musical theater.
As a Christian I am not offended by it at all.
You not have to be “religious” to get it...you don’t have to be Austrian to enjoy The Sound of Music.
Well, they wanted a "concert". But I agee with the comments above. (Actually, all of them -- this has never been my favorite show, and I'm not religious and even if I were, I'm jewish!)
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it?
These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
I'm a big ALW fan and have seen JCS I don't know how many times... but I'm starting to understand what ALW had been saying about it working in a concert-type of venue better than on a stage.
Heaven on their minds was fantastic. Incredibly impressed so far...
Oh wow - Bareiles "Everything is Alright" - she nailed that.
BTW - I consider myself a devout Catholic and have always loved JCS for what it was - an attempt to look at the life of Jesus through the eyes of Judas. As for Jesus not coming back from the dead, Judas wouldn't have known, since he had killed himself by then.
^ There are definitely still some folks out there who find it blasphemous. I was in a regional production in 2016 and there was a protestor at every performance handing out pamphlets detailing all of the "blasphemous" things in the show.
chernjam said: "I'm a big ALW fan and have seen JCS I don't know how many times... but I'm starting to understand what ALW had been saying about it working in a concert-type of venue better than on a stage.
Heaven on their minds was fantastic. Incredibly impressed so far...
Oh wow - Bareiles "Everything is Alright" - she nailed that.
BTW - I consider myself a devout Catholic and have always loved JCS for what it was - an attempt to look at the life of Jesus through the eyes of Judas. As for Jesus not coming back from the dead, Judas wouldn't have known, since he had killed himself by then."
This set is absolutely enormous! I feel like it would work better in a more intimate space. The ensemble just seems to be there to fill up space so far. But Legend, BVD & Bareilles sound great.
seaweedjstubbs said: "^ There are definitely still some folks out there who find it blasphemous. I was in a regional production in 2016 and there was a protestor at every performance handing out pamphlets detailing all of the "blasphemous" things in the show."
Those that do are dogmatic and stuck in a very dark age.
I’m loving it. Gorgeous set, great choreography, and everyone sounds fantastic. I agree that the audience needs to chill out and they need better sound mixing, but other than that, no complaints so far.
What exactly does the religious controversy surrounding JCS, which famously surrounded the album and show in the 70s and may or may not still exist, have to do with whether many have a religious regard for the show or experience it in a very religious way. Even in the 70s, millions found JCS to be religiously evocative and stimulating. And no doubt many still do.
Which doesn't mean one has to have that kind of response to the show to love and admire it. Far from it.
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it?
These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
henrikegerman said: "What exactly does thereligiouscontroversy surrounding JCS, which famously surrounded the album and show in the 70sand may or may not still exist, have to do with whether many have a religious regard for the show or experience itin a very religious way. Even in the 70s, millions found JCS to bereligiously evocative and stimulating. And no doubt many still do.
Which doesn't mean one has to have that kind of response to the show to love and admire it. Far from it."
You can have whatever kind of experience you want from it...religious or otherwise. My point was it isn’t controversial or even edgy as it was when first done.