Posted: 12/3/22 at 2:09pm
ErmengardeStopSniveling said: "Green also knows his audience: the reader, not the artist; considering the NYC population is less than 11% Asian, Green is writing for a mostly non-Asian theatergoing bloc."
A terrible take, especially as Green usually tries to contextualize his reviews in the larger history of theater or understanding of a genre. Why is it relevant to talk about commedia dell'arte or British kitchen sink plays or to remark on trends in dementia plays or family dramas in recent seasons but not show any similar respect to the type of storytelling advanced by KPOP? Also, there was a much higher proportion of Asian audience members when I saw the show.
I don't think only "target audiences" should review shows but I found that all the female critics who got Only Gold were able to speak about it in a different way that made me wish for a greater diversity among critics for the big ticket shows to reflect different perspectives. There should be more voices in theater criticism and if there are consistent issues with an outlet, that's something worth addressing rather than suggesting that there's value in critics like Green telling white audiences that they should stay away from certain shows. I wasn't particularly fired up about the "squint-inducing" comment but the responses here to Asian artists speaking up for themselves are very disappointing. I'm not even defending my new favorite show... I thought it was just fine and mostly carried by the performances.