Was Vanessa Williams really that big a star in 1995 to warrant an entirely new cast recording (on a different record label), or was that a Garth Drabinsky stunt?
I don't know the specific reason as to why the cast recording was made, but yes, she was riding a tidal wave of success at the time. She already bounced back from the Miss America scandal by producing her first hit single, Dreamin', in 1988. By 1994, she had two more successful albums, and a #1 hit single, Save the Best for Last, which was also featured in the popular Australian flick, Adventures of Priscilla. Her Broadway debut in Spider Woman was a pretty big deal at the time. The other replacements for Aurora, Carol Lawrence and Maria Conchita Alonso, didn't come close to the impact Vanessa made, which was one of the best-reviewed Broadway replacements in the last 25 years.
My only quibble with Williams is her stylistic choice to slide down the note at the end of every phrase. Regardless, I adore her. I still think she's the most beautiful woman on the planet and I have massive crazy respect for her. The way she bounced back was amazing for any woman, but for a POC in the 80s-90s, it was EXTRAORDINARY.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian