Play Esq. said: "Can we please just ignore this loser? They'd be gone in a week if they didn't get attention.
Back to the main question of replacement:
Nicholas Hoult, Chris Pine,Timothée Chalamet,Nicholas Galitzine,Jacob Elordi,Austin Butler, and of course, Tom Holland, would all make a good amount of change at the box office (If Matthew Morrison could play this role, who I adored in this role,so can all of the above). Wishful thinking, but I can see any one of them doing it for the cred (and a potential Tony), despite the massive pay loss, provided it’s a short dedication. Whether they can singis another matter.
Chris Pine is way too old (handsome, but looks older than he is IMO). Why would any of them take on a supporting role in a show that is sorta niche in the first place. Unless there is some TV person I am not thinking of (like the Hearststopper duo) who can sing and wants a chance to play Broadway, they are going to have a problem.
One thing I am unclear about: is this going to happen or is it a fishing expedition? I think that would be great at the Booth.