I like the score, but I think that the book is really bad. Like, fascinatingly bad, to the point where I could write a whole essay on what I dislike about it. Here are some of my issues with the book. Keep in mind that I'm a huge fan of the movie, and obviously all of this is my opinion:
- They basically took the same jokes from the movie, then reworded them to make them somehow less funny ("Happy people don't kill!" for instance).
- The new jokes are either offensive (like, literally laughing at this guy's funny-sounding ethnic name or Enid being lesbian) or just pop culture references/product placement ("Gentlemen, please! This isn't Match.com!"
- They made it so Elle didn't even get into Harvard on her own merits. They took the scene from the movie, which actually showed that Elle got in because she had qualifications, and made it into "oh we should admit her because she's hot." They also made Elle too stupid to apparently write an essay, which would have gotten her application thrown out in the first place. Oh, and Elle has to convince the admissions guy to let her in because of "love." In the movie, she doesn't have to convince anyone.
- SPEAKING of. By increasing Emmet's role, they took away Elle's accomplishments of improving her grades and working hard all on her own. In the movie, she figures out that she has to do it without anyone telling her. Also, that scene where she confronts Paulette's ex, in the film she figures out it was a common law marriage all on her own. In the stage version, Emmett has to prompt her.
- They made Vivian's character development downright confusing.
- I think that it was a huge mistake to omit the female law professor from the stage version.
- I also maintain that setting the "perm" scene in the bathroom was stupid, but that's more of a personal thing.
Jimmy, what are you doing here in the middle of the night? It's almost 9 PM!
Updated On: 4/18/17 at 07:46 AM