Saw Hadestown tonight; last time I saw it was during Broadway previews. Show is tight and in great shape.
Timothy Oliver Reid struck me as the direct opposite of Andre de Shields-- his voice was booming and beautiful, but that charm, wry wink, wasn't there. I dont know who decided to do him up with the thick moustache but he looked like Mr Peanut. And I really really missed "aiiiiiight"
No shade to Tom Hewitt, but I missed Patrick Page. And no shade to Amber Gray, but Jewelle Blackman was a dream. The chorus is in top form, too. Unreal cohesion, move like a unit. And whereas I thought Eva sorta faded into the background when I first saw it (was shocked she was Tony nominated, it seemed like such a small role), I thought she was the centerpiece tonight. That voice.
Finally, I don't know what the hell Reeve Carney is doing; when people complained about him back when it opened, I defended him as finding a really unique fine line between "touched" and leading man. But his portrayal seems to have gone off the rails, and when he isnt nailing those high notes, hes whisper-singing through the score. Just bizarre, though hes still giving it his all years in.