I totally understand the sadness of finding out a favorite song was replaced out of town or in previews, but without having seen the run in DC, I can say that these new songs don’t stick out in a bad (or good) way here. They fit right in with the rest of the score.
In fact, after hearing from a friend who saw it in DC that the score was disappointingly mediocre and then reading some comments here that it felt generic, upon hearing the opening number last night I thought, “this isn’t so bad.” I was bracing myself for inept, but it’s far from the embarrassing scores we’ve heard of late like First Date, Scandalous and Amazing Grace. (Yikes, what a trio is that list!)
Comparing this to Legally Blonde- Well I think Legally Blonde has a better story, even just comparing the two films, but I think if you liked the previous show you’ll like this one too. I find Legally Blonde’s score to be highly inconsistent. The good stuff- mostly for Elle- like Omigod/What You Want/So Much Better is candy coated pop confection that is, well, so much better than anything in Mean Girls. Then again, Mean Girls doesn’t make us suffer through any Blood in the Water clunkers either. It maintains its level of quality throughout. Mean Girls desperately needs some Omigod You Guys type catchy number. There’s just no real earworm, and for a pop show like this there should be one.
Another problem Mean Girls inherits from the film is that Cady is the least interesting character of the four female leads (five, if you now count Janis). Unlike Elle, who is clearly the lovable lead and heart of Legally Blonde, we watch Mean Girls for the Plastics. They’re the stars of the show. I think the musical could have helped tip the scales back in Cady’s favor by giving her some knockout numbers, but they’re just not there. She nearly needs a So Much Better to close out the act and solo in the math class about being stupid in love (sorry, no song list in the Playbill) is the reason people are calling the score generic.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!