bear88 said: "As near as I can tell, about 7 or 8 people on this thread have actually seen the show thus far, and some of them were just commenting on the absence of Playbills or praised it.
A couple of those people either don’t like Sondheim shows in general orMerrilyin particular. That’s fine, as they’re entitled to their opinions, but it’s not really a wave of negativity from people who expected to like the revival but didn’t."
I can see being cool on this production. I haven't seen it since it was on the West End, but discussion of things like the sparkly curtain make me think that the production itself hasn't changed. I agree that it's a bit hampered by what feels like an overwhelming desire to create a "respectable" version of this show, which highlights a lot of the show's issues as it currently stands. Frank Jr being wheeled out for cuteness points is particularly schmaltzy.
On the other hand, it plays down the schtick as much as possible, which gives the actors a lot of room to create subtleties with their characters (I remember thinking it was apropos that it was at the Pinter in London), so it's very intimate and detailed. I'm very curious about the chemistry between Groff, Mendez, and Radcliffe, who are all terrific performers and they have a lot to play with.