Just got back from the show tonight. It was super, super fun. As an experience alone I loved it, but when looking at it technically I would give it a 7/10.
There are some great moments and BRILLIANT direction and choreography, but the whole trajectory of the show is a little lost story and character-wise. With more solidified songs for Cady and Regina, this can be fixed. Regina needs a big song near the top of Act One to establish her power and the rest will make sense. Not sure if it's Taylor Louderman or the writing, but beyond not having a big song the role didn't 100% work. The other two plastics were phenomenal and had the audience in the palms of their hands. Ashley's facial expressions are spot on and her nuanced acting does the character wonders. I was, though, confused about her wonderful and sentimental song in Act One and how it didn't really ever come around by the end of the show. It was a nice moment but didn't help Gretchen's arc in the long run.
Barrett and Grey are amazing and are clearly having a lot of fun. I wish they had a strong duet just for the two of them in one of their rooms or at the mall plotting or something-just something where it's only the two of them in the spotlight. It seemed like they were tagged into a lot of things here and there except for Janis's "I'd Rather be Me" song...
I've never seen Kerry Butler be so amazing. She killed all three of her roles.
Ensemble was great. Ben Cook, Jonalyn Saxer, and Nikhil Saboo are clear standouts- they had great energy and can dance like mofos. I loved the choreography and staging-Nicholaw is brilliant and this aspect of the piece is top-notch. The desk-ography and transitions between classes in the first school scene blew my mind and was so inventive. Loved the cafeteria and tray work, definitely hints of Newsies. Definitely hints of Mormon in the opening song, as well with the Africa stuff-specifically Mrs. Brown as Rafiki type stuff.
Additionally-small thing, but one of the panels of one of the screen walls was out. It was on for a bit, and kept glitching, until I guess they decided it best to turn it off. Hopefully it's fixed ASAP because it was distracting! Heard some comments about it on the way out of the theatre.
Overall I would say between now and Broadway it just needs focus. More defined songs with catchy melodies will help the commercial level of success and campy yet sometimes sentimental style that they clearly want and are going for. Regina and Cady need their own new songs, give something to Janis and Damien. Cut the Mrs. George song, Kerry is great and shines in the other material-we didn't need that little diddy. They could have a hit on their hands. For whatever it is, it is definitely a fun night out. And PLEASE add something about Karen being able to tell if it is raining by touching her boobs-iconic line that I did miss.
xx
Updated On: 11/23/17 at 01:02 AM