Posted: 9/12/19 at 2:55pm
Kad said: "I will fully cop to being someone who is not particularly moved by the well-worn melodramatic romantictropes of the movie, nor do I find those tropes to be indicative of "heart" or some sort of emotional complexity or depth.
The production largely eschews those tropes in favor of spectacle and entertainment, which I think is equally valid, and feeling thrilled and dazzled and entertained is just as valid of a response as being emotionally moved- provided that's what the intention is.
I think there is a recurring theme of weirdsnobbishness running through this thread, from people balking that it's a spectacle and thinking it should just be in Vegas to people repeatedly saying they don't recognize a lot of the music used, as if being unaware of the last 2 decades of popular music is a sign of street cred here. (...I also think the claim of audiences laughing every time a new song starts is vastly overblown, but this is admittedly based on my sole experience of having seen the show).
The irony is that most of the successful Broadway musicals with original scores of the last 10+ years all have scores that have been influenced as much by songs and artists like those in Moulin Rouge as they have been by musical theatre, if not more."
Agree completely! Well said Kad!