I went on Wednesday night. Stupidly, I hadn't realized that I bought a ticket for the day after the election, so I certainly was in a pretty somber mood when I got to the theatre. I'm very glad I ended up going, because it was a beautiful night and the final moments felt particularly cathartic. I had more or less held myself together all day, but when those piano chords for Natasha and Pierre began, I lost it and bawled until the end of the show. On such a nasty day with so much hate flying around, it was so helpful to bask in a moment of stillness, kindness, and beauty.
If Rachel Chavkin doesn't win a Tony for this, I'll be shocked. The way she's directed this show for a large theatre is masterful- the big energetic moments are excellent, of course, but just as good are the moments where the staging slows down and is all about simplicity. The last two songs are the perfect example of this- the staging is very sparse, but it's just right. Sam Pinkleton's choreography compliments her work very well. There's not much, but it all works- and the Balaga sequence is absolutely thrilling and totally delightful.
The design work is also stunning. Mimi Lien is a McArthur Genius for a reason, and it certainly shows in the way she's completely transformed the Imperial. Bradley King's lighting design is equally gorgeous, and while some may have found the comet underwhelming, I though the simplicity made it all the more powerful. Paloma Young's costumes and Nicholas Pope's sound design are equally as well-done.
I was very surprised by Josh Groban- he sounds great, which I expected, but I thought he really tapped into Pierre's pathetic nature, which paid off emotionally by the show's end. I was slightly less taken with Denee Benton. Her portrayal of Natasha nails the innocence and foolishness, but I didn't quite get a sense of danger from her during her scenes with Anatole. Still, I liked her quite a bit, and No One Else was a definite highlight. The whole cast is worth mention, but I'll single out Lucas Steele, very effective (and very sexy...those pants) as Anatole, and Amber Gray, who makes a meal of Charming as Helene.
I get that this show might not be for everyone, but I thought it was a magical night with one of the best and most interesting scores to reach Broadway in the past decade. And after such an awful night for the country, it was really so great to be transported away for a few hours and have a perfect place to let everything out.
I am a firm believer in serendipity- all the random pieces coming together in one wonderful moment, when suddenly you see what their purpose was all along.