bryan2 said: "I am listening to this now and I am so confused that they basically got rid of so many songs
ME/Home/Human Again/If I cant Love her/ A Change in me its as if this completely new ...
I have never heard of a Musical that was made into a film where they took so much music away...
I think the old songs were much better than the new ones...I am not hating it..but ???????
"
Emphasis added. Historical note: in fact, it was the custom for the first couple of decades of Hollywood musical adaptations to cut out-of-hand any song from the stage version that had not been a commercial hit. The Hollywood thinking was, "If it were a good song, it would have become a standard." New songs were written to replace the rejects, often written by songwriters other than the original stage writers.
It wasn't until the Rodgers & Hammerstein musicals of the 1950s that Hollywood realized the public was by then listening to CAST ALBUMS (78s then 33 1/3s), not singles, and had fallen in love with entire scores, not just hit songs. So movie musicals began to be adapted with most of the original score intact.
Don't mean to be a smart ass about this. I'm just filling in an important part of movie musical history. I don't know what motivated the subbing of songs in the new BATB. I assume it wasn't an attempt to make commercial hits, but it might have been to add enough new songs to dominate the Best Song category at the Oscars. I'd like to think the filmmakers have more integrity, but I don't know them.