Posted: 12/8/25 at 12:26pm
Saw this on Saturday night. I found the production incredibly moving from the very first moments. The energy on stage is absolutely electric, in no small part due to the incredible cast. It's such a privilege to see a collection of Broadway stars at the top of their craft doing such fantastic work.
Joshua Henry is getting most of the attention, and deservedly so. His voice is just insane in the room. There were moments where I felt like they may have cut his mic as his voice filled the room adequately on it's own. I know Caissie Levy has gotten some criticisms here, but I was so invested in her portrayal of Mother. Such a lived in and compelling performance of the character. Brandon Uranowitz was incredible and endlessly likable. I wasn't ready for how different I was going to find Ben Levi Ross' as Younger Brother, but I haven't stopped thinking about many of his choices, in a good way.
The show is long, but I personally felt like I didn't want it to end. I cannot imagine anything as entertaining and moving as what's going on at the Vivian Beaumont right now. It could have been five hours and I wouldn't have minded.
There are issues with the book (as there have always been) that I'm probably just used to so wasn't bothered by. The only big issue I had was the staging of "Wheels of a Dream." The stage was just too bare for me. Henry and Lewis are selling the **** out of that number, but I really needed the titular car on that stage with them. It would have made the car's destruction a few scenes later more impactful.