Hmmmm.......here goes. (Saw the show on Thursday with TDF tix; seats in the last row, center orch next to the sound booth -- sightlines were absolutely fine, not even cut off because of the overhang.
TONS of production team in the house, which I was likely MORE aware of because of my seats, and one such somebody was sitting next to me. They were audible when tech things or gags seems to go well, but not really terribly distracting. (Annie Golden was in the house, btw.)
I agree with lots of the comments here, good and bad. It's workable, but right now it's just not well developed.
The Characters/Performances: While I never felt that they were copying performances from the movie, I felt they were nearly all two dimensional characters but don't truly fault the actors, but the book. (See below.) I did fine that both Rocky and Adrian were well done, but didn't feel moved/interested in any other characters.
The Set: While impressive, I felt it was over designed. Did it ever take away from the show? No, but I didn't feel it ever really added all that much either.
The Book: This is the biggest problem (IMO). NOTHING and NO ONE truly gets developed. We don't truly get to know the characters, so we don't really see any growth/development. Adrian...we don't truly see her awkwardness, so her arc isn't really a huge deal. Rocky...again, where is his growth? Even his training doesn't really work: do we ever see him OUT of shape? Except for his failing at the stairs once, where is the struggle? Let's speak to the arc of both Paulie and Mickey: Where is their development? How can Adrian sing the Act II number when the worst thing we ever see Paulie do is throw the turkey out the window? (Which, btw, would be a better moment if we believed for even a moment that it wasn't a prop weighing just a few ounces.) What about the scene in the butcher shop? We go from Rocky saying he won't hit the meat, to pounding it for the cameras. So many moments that you'd only understand IF you'd seen the film that are just glossed over. Which is another problem with the show....the story just goes from one big moment in the film to the next...without the ingredients to really make it work. The actors aren't given the motivation/story line to make many of those scenes work. I'll agree with the comments that there are too many short scenes...which is why development isn't happening.
The Score: Not impressed. Yes,these are working class, uneducated people -- but there is a difference between rustic/non-refined and stupid. They aren't stupid. I cannot hum a single tune that I didn't already know. I agree that a 70s feel (or any feel at all) would have been welcome. I heard a similar conversation during intermission.
The Boxing/Final Fight: It didn't win me over. I felt lots of the fighting looked incredibly fake. How can I punch you, if you don't take the hit? The balance just wasn't there. I found the scripted parts to feel incredibly artificial...maybe because you HAD to look at the screens. But that removed me from the story and any personal connection I might have started to feel. And (this needs to be yelled) I DON'T NEED TO BE BLINDED BY THE LIGHTS WITH EVERY HIT OR ROUND CHANGE! WTH? I also found the the last tableau, between Rocky and Adrian just awkward and after school special-like. It's not their declaration of love that ends the story, its his achieving of the goal -- a goal that wasn't all that well established.
I didn't hate the show, but felt disappointed. The moments that worked the best were between Rocky and Adriane. And the scenes with 1/2 clothed men.

I can't really reccommend this show to many, nor will I try to dissuade anyone. My son enjoyed the show, it was it first introduction to the story. (Now we have the movie scheduled for the DVR tomorrow night....we'll see if his opnion and/or understanding change with that.) He gives it an 8 out of 10, while I'd be giving it a 6.5.
The audience, however, ate it up. Quick to get on their feet. I saw/heard no phones or obnoxious behavior, nor any moaning and groaning with the songs. Yes, it didn't seem like a typical audience (more men, fewer senior citizens) but they were appropriate in every way.
BTW....I really loved the curtain during intermission, found it to be very clever.
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it?
These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
Updated On: 2/21/14 at 03:58 PM