I wanted so badly to love The Band's Visit. I went to NYC for 11 days and saw a lot of musicals and plays, as I usually do. This is one that I was honestly looking forward to so much.
I love movies like this. I've seen The Band's Visit years ago, and loved it. When I heard that they were making a musical version, I knew I just had to see it.
It honestly lacked the magic that it had on screen, in my opinion.
The songs, besides 'Omar Sharif' and its reprises, were so forgettable that I don't really remember them at all. And, I just saw it days ago. 'Omar Sharif' stands out, and, it had two reprises, but... I feel like some of the songs dragged on, and on, and on.
The chemistry between the two main leads wasn't all that strong.
The character development tried to follow the movie closely, but, I felt that there was still a lot missing in that aspect.
Some very small characters had some songs (telephone guy) but I feel like a song slot should have gone to, say... Tewfiq, who doesn't really sing AT ALL during the show except for a tiny bit.
As I said, the chemistry wasn't really there, for me.
The songs, except for a small handful, were extremely forgettable.
The relationships / friendships felt extremely forced.
Not enough story building. Not enough character development.
I'm not the type to only go for big flashy musicals, too. My favorite musical experience of all time was Daddy Long Legs off-Broadway, which was small and intimate. I like small, intimate, and cozy sentimental musicals. But this one... I don't think it was done exceptionally well.
I normally never compare movies to their musical counterparts, but in this case, I will.
The movie is much more raw, powerful, and had a much bigger impact on me.
I went with three friends. One of my friends is Jewish and wanted to see this musical very badly. My other two friends wanted to see Tony Shalhoub. I was the only one in my party who had seen the movie before.
None of my friends really liked this one at all. They all said it was very forgettable. Everyone loved the song 'Omar Sharif' and one of my friends did like it more than the rest, but at the end of the day, even they were kinda... ehhhh.... about it.