Besides minor changes here and there, this was indeed the same thing as Paper Mill. That said, Nick seems to be the storyteller as he makes the first appearance instead of Gatsby. He comes a few scenes later.
The Gas Station scene features an EVEN BIGGER eye glass billboard which is even more creepy and takes up almost half the stage.
The new song “New Money” is poorly written but I’m happy Samantha Pauly finally gets a belting number. Also, the choreography was pretty good in that number.
Fair warning, the show stopped for like 2 minutes just for Jeremy’s entrance so brace yourself for that.
My Green Light was a lot better vocally.
Act II was pretty much the same as Paper Mill with the exception of the orchestra making an onstage appearance in Gatsby’s party scene.