Well, that was cute. Not $175 a ticket cute, but it was cute.
Lately, I find myself walking out of shows a little sad that there is so much unrealized potential that otherwise very talented people don't take advantage of.
Last night, it was All My Sons and tonight, it's Tootsie.
There's a lot to like here, not the least of which is that much of the show is very funny and it's nice to have a book of a musical that makes you laugh out loud.
I don't have the same quibble with the music as others. It's not memorable or great, but, it mostly fits the characters and doesn't stop the show cold. It's not music I will listen to, again, but it was fine within the context of the show. Admittedly, I'm not sure "fine" is what you want in a very expensive Broadway musical.
Santino Fontana was good, but it felt like you could see him working really hard on the stage and so, I never felt totally blown away by him.
The cast was mostly good but never rose to greatness, save Sarah Stiles who is very funny. Julie Halston, whom I love, is wasted.
As was said, the sets are a bit odd...realism and cartoon, with no consistency, but it didn't bother me.
What did bother me is that things just happen. The transformation just happens. The "love" interest just happens. Wouldn't an employer know that either Michael or Dorothy is using a fake ID? Etc...., but I was willing to go with it for the laughs.
But, let's talk about that ending. What an atrocious ending to an otherwise fun evening. I agree the curtain call is unnecessarily awkward and left us with a bit of a bad taste. Cut that odd Mamma Mia mega mix thing that comes out of nowhere, please.
My companion who also thought it was fun, thinks this is a 100 minute musical padded into 2 hours and 40 minutes. I pretty much agree.
I would recommend this for laughs. Just don't pay full price.
FOR ANYONE DOING WILL CALL: Will call is a mess. Tonight, we got on the will call line about 7:35 and didn't get to our seats until 8:05. The line wrapped around the outside of the box office, more than once. You might want to get there earlier than we did to pick up your tickets.