Petralicious said: "A friend of mine saw the show last week with Carliegh Betttol as Eliza and said she was amazes, anyone else have the pleasure?"
I have seen Phillipa, Carleigh, and Alysha in the role. I thought Carleigh was a beautiful, tender Eliza. She has trouble with big notes, but acting-wise and in 95% of Eliza's score, I thought she nailed it.
Nobody can match the utter, ethereal beauty that Phillipa brought to the role, but I was super pleased with Carleigh. Alysha, on the other hand—not so pleased. Thought she played Eliza with much more fury and bite than I think the character ought to have.
Further, Carleigh kept the loud cry Eliza makes after Philip's death as well as the gasp at the finale. Alysha did not. I was much less emotionally affected by Alysha's Eliza than Carleigh's, and of course far less than Phillipa's.
If you can't tell, I have rather strong thoughts on the portrayal of Eliza, so I apologize for my rambling verbosity 