I feel bad ragging on a show that’s so earnest and heart-on-its-sleeve and attempting to illuminate a piece of gay history worth illuminating, but I thought TVU was really… really not good. The music is an unmelodic and bland tapestry of era-specific homage cum generic showtune sounds. Even when you do find yourself in a little groove with it here and there, you won’t remember why the second the song ends.
The lyrics are worse and on par with the dialogue. You won’t need your own thoughts because nearly everything that comes from the characters’ mouths is as subtle as a brickbat. They all say exactly what’s on their mind, all the time, every time, and it’s usually platitudinal. It’s all tell and no show.
The magical realism is confusing. The ‘70s characters are baffled by a smartphone – rightly so – but later on seem to understand the social conventions and mechanics of app usage when it’s important for our contemporary hero to have a conversation with them about their merits, with no substantial explanation ever having been given to the past-era characters. The show is full of head-scratchers like that.
The set truly is terrific, and Nathan Lee Graham is a treasure. God bless him for making so much out of this material. His centerpiece monologue is likely the only content I’ll remember about this show five years from now. Oh, and Taylor Frey wears these tight blue pants throughout which you can distract yourself with when your mind wanders… and that may be frequently.
Intellectually speaking, a story in which a 21st-century gay gets to exchange ideas firsthand with ‘70s-era gays about their respective foibles and joys and culture-specific mores etc could be richly mined for drama. It could also be heavy-handed and preachy. TVU most definitely falls prey to being the latter.
Now…all that being said, I don’t regret seeing it. It’s still a scrappy little new downtown musical with flashes of possibility and, as I said, a big heart. I didn’t expect much going in and was still let down. So, if you go – and you should – expect a sort of repetitive, super-gay after-school musical special with all of your favorite gay cultural tokens each getting Their Big Moment to Shine. Oh, and those blue pants.
CHURCH DOOR TOUCAN GAY MARKETING PUPPIES MUSICAL THEATER STAPLES PERIOD OIL BITCHY SNARK HOLES