I've tried to collect my thoughts as best i can so here we go..
First of all I have to say Patti and Christine are giving the performance of a lifetime in these roles. Amazing work vocally and acting wise from both. What I loved about this was the story, the importance of it, the score, the ladies etc. The opening number "A Woman's Face" is perfect and it sets the tone very well. I can't get it out of my head (as well as most of the score, if anyone has a naughty audio recording please send it my way!!). I personally didn't mind the format of the show. Some people on here said it was like vignette's to them. I personally saw the story cohesively and understood it. That being said, most of the score is brilliant.. most of the time. I think some of the songs need reworking to make them stronger. I'm talking about some of the lesser ones like the duet between Arden and her husband. I'd also like to see "Better yourself" expanded a little more. I love both acts but I thought "Face to Face", "War Paint", "If I were a man", "Pink", "Now You Know" and "Forever Beautiful" were the best songs. I also loved the last song the ladies sing but I wish they could incorporate another reprise of A Women's Face at the end of the show. I thought the second act itself was brilliant. The scene where the two ladies meet was perfect. It's exactly what the audience wants and it's truly perfect. Overall it's in great shape. It's a great show. Others who I talked to did not think so which is worrisome. The quality in this material is off the charts. It's such an important story that needs to be told. I'm not sure if this will be a great commercial production, but it will certainly be an artistic triumph. The bad: as i've said the weaker songs need to be tweaked, the mens material is interesting. I get that Dinosaurs is supposed to be the comic relief and the men do make the most of it but I'd rather see a book scene instead. This is just me being selfish but does anyone think there is room for a actual quartet for the two ladies and men? I think it would be a nice moment. I mean did Arden's husband ever miss her? Did Harry miss working for Rubenstein? I think either way these dynamics should and could be explored a little more. Either way I can't wait to see this show again (assuming there's a transfer in the works). I was blown away. I think this is one of the best new musicals as of late... Also I'm going to read the book now and watch the documentary. If you have a chance to see this show RUN RUN RUN. Totally worth it. Pure brilliance. (I apologize if this is rambling)