Wicked Movie Seeks New Director — Page 8

Valentina3 said: "Oh man didn't realize I'd start a critical review book club but this is fun to read. I have never thought that hard about Wicked's plot holes, as glaring as they are - mostly because it's far too much fun to just let the show take you wherever it wants to go. I don't find it confusing because before you can actually think about an issue, they throw something at you which is, to user an earlier poster's word, "charming".

I'm sure they'll have to work out some of this stuff. Plot holes don't fly super well anymore in movies, but the only thing I currently care about is the cast."

Stephen Schwartz said himself that things might work on stage, but won't fly on film. He and Winnie Holzman have spent so much time really honing the screenplay.

This thread has taken a great turn the discussion of the plot holes in the musical and the analysis of the original novel. Gregory Maguire's novel is one of my favorite books of all time, and I have read it many times. Each time a read it, I find something new. There is no doubt that the musical just took the concept of the novel and watered it down and sweetened it up immensely to appeal to the masses. The novel is extremely dark, political, and violent.

One thing that has always REALLY bothered me about the stage adaptation is that the design is entirely based on the idea of the Clock of the Time Dragon (a pivotal plot point and symbol in the novel), but the musical references the clock only a couple times in passing.

---

It will be really interesting to see if Chu bases his Oz on Maguire’s fully realised version or like the campy Wizard of Oz version that OZ: THE GREAT AND POWERFUL based their version on.

One of the things I love about the books is how Oz feels like a real country with politics and races and all sorts going on rather than a fairytale land a small girl made up in her head.

In regards to casting I’d love to see Helen Mirren as Morrible or even Miriam Margolyes reprise her role! Emmy Raver Lampman definitely seems like the most obvious choice for Elphaba given that she’s played the role before and has proven she can act on film and TV.

My only concern is how Chu will approach the belting since modern musicals seem to shy away from letting people belt their faces off on screen, with the exception of DREAMGIRLS.

---

NOWaWarning said: "Plannietink08 said: "My only concern is how Chu will approach the belting since modern musicals seem to shy away from letting people belt their faces off on screen, with the exception of DREAMGIRLS. "

I’m less concerned that the belting will make it in than I am about Glinda’s higher soprano moments. I feel like we heareven less high, borderline operatic singing in modern movie musicals."

I think Glinda's soprano pyrotechnics won't be a problem in the film.

SporkGoddess said: "NOWaWarning said: "Plannietink08 said: "My only concern is how Chu will approach the belting since modern musicals seem to shy away from letting people belt their faces off on screen, with the exception of DREAMGIRLS. "

I’m less concerned that the belting will make it in than I am about Glinda’s higher soprano moments. I feel like we heareven less high, borderline operatic singing in modern movie musicals."

ME TOO. Hollywood cannot cast legit sopranos. They'll cast someone with a thin voice and no breath support. Everyone will talk about how it was better because the singer sounded much more"nice and "innocent" because the average person apparently hates well sunghigh notes.

Sorry, it's not like I'm bitter or anything..."

They should cast a stage actress. Maybe one of the Christine's from Phantom or Brittney Johnson from the Broadway production.

Samantha Barks and Amanda Seyfried are by far the most exciting rumored casting I have heard so far.

---

I like Seyfried, but her singing has far too much vibrato - can't stand listening to it.

---

I love Seyfried, but she can't sing very well. Very weak voice with that overused vibrato to attempt to mask notes she can't hit.I imagine the Wicked producers are open to creating an auto-tuned soundtrack (pretty much the norm these days). No one in movie musicals nowadays can sing. Well, some can carry a tune but they can't sing the score as written. Their vocals all get fixed and strengthened in the mixing.

If she wins the Oscar, expect her to get cast. God, if Streep shows up as Morrible (I hope to god she doesn't-give someone else a chance) it will be Mamma Mia 3.

---

Amanda's acting would be really good but I think her singing isn't up for the vocal demands. Maybe Dove Cameron could be a better fit, her vocal range turns out to be very flexible and she was in a production of The Light in The Piazza where apparently she was really good in it.

Also I think Ariana DeBose or Samantha Barks would be great choices for Elphaba.

Bettyboy72 said: "I love Seyfried, but she can't sing very well. Very weak voice with that overused vibrato to attempt to mask notes she can't hit.I imagine the Wicked producers are open to creating an auto-tuned soundtrack (pretty much the norm these days). No one in movie musicals nowadays can sing. Well, some can carry a tune but they can't sing the score as written. Their vocals all get fixed and strengthened in the mixing.

If she wins the Oscar, expect her to get cast. God, if Streep shows up as Morrible (I hope to god she doesn't-give someone else a chance) it will be Mamma Mia 3."

Well she’s definitely not winning the Oscar, she’s didn’t win the Globe and got snubbed at both Bafta and SAG.

---

Updated On: 4/9/21 at 02:36 PM

I've listened to the interview just now and Amanda has stated she has had singing lessons three days a week through out lockdown and its never been better for hitting the notes. She also sings a tiny bit of the intro of No One mourns the wicked "Let us be glad.." nothing at all to judge her by. She also acknowledges that she was not ready to play the part eight years back because her voice wasn't ready for it.

I think she and Lady Gaga would be a great pairing together, Amanda seems to want Anna Kendrick thought but I think they'll go for a woman if colour to play the part because it's so relative to Elphaba's story.

Updated On: 4/9/21 at 04:11 PM

Musical Master said: "It's interesting that she's been having singing lessons for a while, maybe her vocalshas improved, I guess if she is Glinda we'll wait and see how it turns out."

I'd love Kaley Ann Voorhees to play Glinda