TGMAG - FINALS: McDonald vs. Ripley- Page 2

[SNLMedia]

Posted: 4/17/09 at 7:58pm

Audra McDonald - 4
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 3
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 1
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 1
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 1
Marin Mazzie - 1
Julia Murney - 1
Victoria Clark - 1
Leslie Kritzer - 1

[MisterRussell]

Posted: 4/17/09 at 9:08pm

Just another popularity contest. What a waste of time and energy.

[PiraguaGuy2]

Posted: 4/17/09 at 10:31pm

Victoria Clark is ineligible. She was born in 1959. Shame - I love her.

Audra McDonald - 4
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 3
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 1
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 1
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 1
Marin Mazzie - 1
Julia Murney - 1
Leslie Kritzer - 1

[markus907]

Posted: 4/17/09 at 10:47pm

Audra McDonald - 4
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 3
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 1
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 1
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 1
Marin Mazzie - 2
Julia Murney - 2
Leslie Kritzer - 1

[roseaddams]

Posted: 4/17/09 at 11:11pm

Audra McDonald - 4
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 3
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 2
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Marin Mazzie - 2
Julia Murney - 2
Leslie Kritzer - 1

[CurtainPullDowner]

Posted: 4/17/09 at 11:13pm

Sherie Renee Scott 1 ???
Aniki Noni Rose 1 ??
Raul Esparza 0

I don't get this game.
or Deal Or No Deal either

[AndAllThatJazz22]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 9:04am

Audra McDonald - 4
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 3
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 2
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Marin Mazzie - 2
Julia Murney - 2
Leslie Kritzer - 1
Sherie Rene Scott - 2
Aniki Noni Rose 1
Karen Olivo - 1

[nomdeplume]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 12:06pm

I'm against the ageist nature of this thread. I choose:


Angela Lansbury - 1

Patti Lupone - 1

Donna Murphy - 1

If you don't like it, go twitter.

[TheActr97J]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 12:08pm

Yeah, why 1960? Victoria Clark was born in '59 so she can't be included? This seems silly.

[Elphaba3]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 3:40pm

Audra McDonald - 4
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 4
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 2
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Marin Mazzie - 2
Julia Murney - 3
Leslie Kritzer - 1
Sherie Rene Scott - 2
Aniki Noni Rose 1
Karen Olivo - 1
Lisa Brescia - 1
Katie Rose Clarke - 1

[rita!]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 4:58pm

Audra McDonald - 4
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 4
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 3
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Marin Mazzie - 3
Julia Murney - 3
Leslie Kritzer - 1
Sherie Rene Scott - 2
Aniki Noni Rose 1
Karen Olivo - 1
Lisa Brescia - 1
Katie Rose Clarke - 1
jenn gambatese - 1

[Theatreboy49]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 5:09pm

Audra McDonald - 4
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 4
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 3
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Marin Mazzie - 3
Julia Murney - 4
Leslie Kritzer - 1
Sherie Rene Scott - 2
Aniki Noni Rose 1
Karen Olivo - 1
Lisa Brescia - 1
Katie Rose Clarke - 1
jenn gambatese - 1

[GatorNY]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 7:07pm

Audra McDonald - 4
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 4
Marin Mazzie - 4
Julia Murney - 4
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 3
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Leslie Kritzer - 1
Sherie Rene Scott - 2
Aniki Noni Rose 1
Karen Olivo - 2
Lisa Brescia - 1
Katie Rose Clarke - 1
jenn gambatese - 1
Elizabeth Stanley- 1
Sasha Allen- 1

[zepka102]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 7:13pm

Audra McDonald - 5
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Kelli O'Hara - 4
Marin Mazzie - 4
Julia Murney - 4
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 3
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Leslie Kritzer - 1
Sherie Rene Scott - 2
Aniki Noni Rose 1
Karen Olivo - 2
Lisa Brescia - 1
Katie Rose Clarke - 1
jenn gambatese - 1
Elizabeth Stanley- 1
Sasha Allen- 1

[singtopher]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 7:16pm

So, What happens after 4? How do we determine the 'greatest'?

[Jon]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 7:20pm

I think to be eligible, you should have originated at least ONE major role in a Broadway musical. Julia Murney's career has been replacements and Off-Broadway.

[bwaylvsong]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 7:39pm

She originated a role in Lennon.

[BroadwayBound115]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 10:00pm

Audra McDonald - 5
Kelli O'Hara - 5
Laura Benanti - 4
Alice Ripley - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Marin Mazzie - 4
Julia Murney - 4
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 3
Karen Olivo - 3
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Leslie Kritzer - 1
Sherie Rene Scott - 2
Aniki Noni Rose 1
Lisa Brescia - 1
Katie Rose Clarke - 1
jenn gambatese - 1
Elizabeth Stanley- 1
Sasha Allen- 1

[feline0favenueQ]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 10:14pm

Alice Ripley - 5
Julia Murney - 5
Audra McDonald - 5
Kelli O'Hara - 5
Laura Benanti - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Marin Mazzie - 4
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 3
Karen Olivo - 3
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Leslie Kritzer - 1
Sherie Rene Scott - 2
Aniki Noni Rose 1
Lisa Brescia - 1
Katie Rose Clarke - 1
jenn gambatese - 1
Elizabeth Stanley- 1
Sasha Allen- 1

[Alexis2]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 10:19pm

there are NONE......No CHITA's, NO GWEN's, NO LIZA's, NO ALEXIS'
NO ETHEL'S, NO MARY's, No ANGELA'S..............not even
a SUSAN JOHNSON or a NANCY WALKER in today's mix.........

Those everyone are listing, aren't even knock-offs or poor
imitations of the ABOVE GREATS.......

As Bette would say " WHY BOTHER"

[Here I Am]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 10:37pm

Why do people have to always put down this generation of actors by always comparing them to the "greats" of yesterday? Can't there be amazing performers today as well? How old school are you? Nobody can even compare to Ethel? Give me a break. "Knock offs"? Just because they weren't born in 1920 doesn't mean they are any less brilliant.
Updated On: 4/18/09 at 10:37 PM

[coryografer]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 10:40pm

Alice Ripley - 5
Julia Murney - 5
Audra McDonald - 5
Kelli O'Hara - 5
Laura Benanti - 4
Sutton Foster - 4
Kristin Chenoweth - 4
Stephanie J. Block - 4
Marin Mazzie - 4
Tonya Pinkins - 2
Tracie Thoms - 2
Lea Salonga - 3
Karen Olivo - 4
Melissa Errico - 1
Carolee Carmello - 3
Megan Hilty - 2
Sara Ramirez - 2
Kerry Butler - 2
Leslie Kritzer - 1
Sherie Rene Scott - 2
Aniki Noni Rose 1
Lisa Brescia - 1
Katie Rose Clarke - 1
jenn gambatese - 2
Elizabeth Stanley- 1
Sasha Allen- 1

[CurtainPullDowner]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 10:45pm

Lea DeLaria 1
She's an actress right?

I know this is about Musical Actrsses, but someone cut the list down to Actresses who have also performed in a straight play, or take a point away from anyone who hasn't,
not jackin' the thread, but it would be interesting.
I believe Audra should win this hands down.

[kchenofan]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 10:55pm

I thought you couldn't vote after 4. Whatever. I'm pulling for Kristin, but I think Audra's gonna win. Please don't crucify me for saying "gonna". I'm from Jersey, it's a habit.

[RentBoy86]

Posted: 4/18/09 at 11:06pm

Sorry, I was confused. But all my eligible points go to "Leslie Kritzer."