Finally caught this last night - I am a huge GYPSY fan, and a *HUGE* Audra fan - she is probably my #1 diva - but sadly this did not do it for me. I found it it to be painted in very broad.strokes.
The production overall lacks the specificity and laser focus required to make the show emotionally affecting, and the fault lies entirely with George C. Wolfe. Everyone, with the exception of Danny Burstein, are playing either highly obvious choices (Audra, Joy Woods) or highly isoteric and out-there choices (Jordan Tyson playing June like her very state of being = emotional breakdown) and playing them so hard, it starts to all feel same-y...so the tension and momentum building up to Rose's breakdown falters. Without that support and set up, even a titan like Audra can't bring the tragedy of the story home - so unfortunately, she has to force it.
Again, this is no fault of Audra's, or really any of the actors - throughout, you can tell that Wolfe is focusing on the wrong things. Most glaringly are...
Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content
the strange cuts to "All I Need is the Girl" that cuts the section where Louise fantasizes about Tulsa lifting her as he describes his act. If Louise is not given the moment to really fall in love with Tulsa, the tragedy of June running away with him is lost. Something that simple creates tension for an audience to feel the tragedy of a moment. Without it, Audra is forced to literally will it out of herself. She does, but then we're watching *her* feel everything, and the audience doesn't get any room to feel themselves.
And then...
Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content
The same thing happens in the leadup to Rose's Turn, where Joy Woods is made to turn Louise's transformation striptease into a big, dance-y production number a la "I'm a Brass Band" in SWEET CHARITY, then is breathlessly thrust into the dressing room scene where she plays the attack, non-stop, the full time - allowing for no peaks and valleys for Audra to build off of. So, Audra is then forced to completely will an emotional breakdown out of herself a second time, pulling on all the empathy she has for her own character to get herself there. She gets there, sure - but it doesn't allow the audience any room to feel, yet again. Worse even, when Woods re-enters for the final scene, she is still directed to be aggressively targeting her mother from the get go - showing no care or empathy - undercutting the show's most gutting line..."just like I wanted you to notice me".
All of the above could be fixed by a sharper directorial focus and knowing when to let the company go full tilt, and when to hold it back (something, all his problems aside, Arthur Laurents did very, very well in the LuPone revival). Somehow Burstein manages to do this despite Wolfe's sloppy hand. The big scenes with Herbie were the most emotionally affecting; Louise's hugging Herbie before "ECUR" elicited a strong emotional response from the audience - as did the breakup scene. But something tells me Burstein got himself there, despite Wolfe.
So, this was a big let down for me. It's a shame, with stronger direction, this would have been a smash.
Oh, but let it be said - the set does not look cheap. I actually found it more effective and opulent than what was used in the LuPone revival. And Audra's singing is sensational - she is very much belting, and yes, also mixing when her voice requires it, but it's a fully effective take on the score and I can't wait to hear her performance (and everyone's, honestly) on recording, where this company will *truly* shine...because Wolfe can't ruin that.